HOME ARTICLES JOIN GALLERY STORE SPONSORS MARKETPLACE CONTACT US  
Register | FAQ | Search | Memberlist
Username:    Password:       Forgot your password?
BIKELAND > FORUMS > ZX-14.com > Thread: Can i sue for damages to my baby? NEW TOPIC NEW POLL POST REPLY
clemson51087


Parking Attendant
Virginia Beach, VA
Posts: 16
posted June 24, 2009 11:51 PM        
Can i sue for damages to my baby?

Last Tuesday i was riding along I64 westbound towards Richmond right before the Hampton roads bridge tunnel in Norfolk VA. when my front tire struck a large rock in the street. This rock was a piece of the asphalt that had broken up out of the interstate and was sitting on top of the highway. this rock was so large it bent my rim when i stuck it and sent me flying over the handle bars at 55 miles an hour. i have taken two safety courses one within the past two months plus i have been riding for over 8 years i am no newbie. this was simply caused by poor roadway maintenance as the roads around here are horrible to begin with. can i sue the company contracted to maintain this stretch of highway or am i simply SOL? She was a 2009 ZX14 Special Edition and i miss her dearly. i have extensive road rash on my lower back and my knees and have two fractured fingers even though i was wearing all of the proper gear.
____________
Your 'Busa looks so much smaller in my rear view than i thought it would.

  Ignore this member   
KLD


Novice Class
Posts: 51
posted June 25, 2009 12:11 AM        
whos to say it didn't fall out of some truck
  Ignore this member   
clemson51087


Parking Attendant
Virginia Beach, VA
Posts: 16
posted June 25, 2009 12:20 AM        
quote:
whos to say it didn't fall out of some truck


i don't know many people who ride around with chunks of asphalt twice the size of a softball in the back of their truck. just saying
____________
Your 'Busa looks so much smaller in my rear view than i thought it would.

  Ignore this member   
KLD


Novice Class
Posts: 51
posted June 25, 2009 12:28 AM        
quote:
quote:
whos to say it didn't fall out of some truck


i don't know many people who ride around with chunks of asphalt twice the size of a softball in the back of their truck. just saying


Asphalt workers who are laying new asphalt, the old stuff just doesn't fly to the concrete yard.

I definetly feel your pain. On my old Kawasaki a peice of shredded tire got lodged in between my brakes and rim and made me eat concrete. It sucks.. but not much you can do

  Ignore this member   
clemson51087


Parking Attendant
Virginia Beach, VA
Posts: 16
posted June 25, 2009 12:35 AM        
quote:
quote:
quote:
whos to say it didn't fall out of some truck


i don't know many people who ride around with chunks of asphalt twice the size of a softball in the back of their truck. just saying


Asphalt workers who are laying new asphalt, the old stuff just doesn't fly to the concrete yard.

I definetly feel your pain. On my old Kawasaki a peice of shredded tire got lodged in between my brakes and rim and made me eat concrete. It sucks.. but not much you can do


Who knows. my lawyer seems pretty confident and he doesn't get paid unless i win so we will see. i have insurance but i want them to pay for their shoddy work. the roads around here are horrible and the DOT doesn't seem to care. i don't want this happening to my fellow riders. the pain i endured when they scrubbed the asphalt out of my wounds i wish on no man. i was on a morphine drip and i was still about to pass out the pain was so intense.
____________
Your 'Busa looks so much smaller in my rear view than i thought it would.

  Ignore this member   
KLD


Novice Class
Posts: 51
posted June 25, 2009 01:43 AM        
quote:
quote:
quote:
quote:
whos to say it didn't fall out of some truck


i don't know many people who ride around with chunks of asphalt twice the size of a softball in the back of their truck. just saying


Asphalt workers who are laying new asphalt, the old stuff just doesn't fly to the concrete yard.

I definetly feel your pain. On my old Kawasaki a peice of shredded tire got lodged in between my brakes and rim and made me eat concrete. It sucks.. but not much you can do


Who knows. my lawyer seems pretty confident and he doesn't get paid unless i win so we will see. i have insurance but i want them to pay for their shoddy work. the roads around here are horrible and the DOT doesn't seem to care. i don't want this happening to my fellow riders. the pain i endured when they scrubbed the asphalt out of my wounds i wish on no man. i was on a morphine drip and i was still about to pass out the pain was so intense.


Thats bad.. if anything it'll most likely get them to maintain the street more

  Ignore this member   
BobC


Pro
Posts: 1736
posted June 25, 2009 03:32 AM        
You would stand a better chance if the poor condition of that stretch of highway had already been reported.
Do you have anything like http://www.potholes.co.uk/ in the USA ?
____________
Candy Thunder Blue 2006 ZZR1400
Stock wheelbase
Max: 205.4 mph in 1.25 miles

2012 ZZR1400 in Golden Blazed Green
Brock CT Full System. etc
Max: 203.1 in 1 mile (so far)

  Ignore this member   
eklipse636


Needs a life
ZX-14
Posts: 6046
posted June 25, 2009 04:20 AM        
That's sucks man. I hate to sound negative, but that's what insurance is for. I understand not wanting to file a claim, but maybe your lawyer can get It sorted out. The down side to your lawyer settling it is it could be a year+ before anything is done. Are you willing to wait for your bike that long?
____________
Best: 60ft 1.351 1/8 5.68 mph 123.98 1/4
8.89 mph 151.32

  Ignore this member   
clemson51087


Parking Attendant
Virginia Beach, VA
Posts: 16
posted June 25, 2009 08:10 AM        
quote:
That's sucks man. I hate to sound negative, but that's what insurance is for. I understand not wanting to file a claim, but maybe your lawyer can get It sorted out. The down side to your lawyer settling it is it could be a year+ before anything is done. Are you willing to wait for your bike that long?


i have a gsxr 600 as well so i will still be riding. besides maybe the 2010's will have even more power.
____________
Your 'Busa looks so much smaller in my rear view than i thought it would.

  Ignore this member   
clemson51087


Parking Attendant
Virginia Beach, VA
Posts: 16
posted June 25, 2009 08:14 AM        
quote:
You would stand a better chance if the poor condition of that stretch of highway had already been reported.
Do you have anything like http://www.potholes.co.uk/ in the USA ?


i don't think so. i believe you have to call them directly to report one but the roads here are so bad that it wouldn't make a difference. the entire interstate is full of snail trails and uneven pavement. some places have signs warning you about potholes but this particular stretch didn't have a sign.
____________
Your 'Busa looks so much smaller in my rear view than i thought it would.

  Ignore this member   
Port_Angeles_NINJA


Expert Class
Posts: 388
posted June 25, 2009 08:43 AM        
Not trying to be a dick but i don't understand how you are riding along at 55mph and don't see a piece of asphalt the size of 2 softballs before hitting it?
____________
Red/Black 85' GPZ900
Blue 07' ZX14

  Ignore this member   
GHOSTMAN


Expert Class
Posts: 456
posted June 25, 2009 08:57 AM        
Were you in traffic at the time?
____________
I'm There Whether You See Me Or Not.

  Ignore this member   
zxbob


Pro
Posts: 1692
posted June 25, 2009 09:27 AM        
I had the same thing happen to me !

I was in a turn and cought it with the front tire ~ the piece flew up and took out
the oil presure sending unit and oiled down the front and rear tires.

The only way I kept controll was head for the dirt and get off the oil slick pavement !






Bob

____________
Good parts aint cheap and cheap parts aint good !

  Ignore this member   
clemson51087


Parking Attendant
Virginia Beach, VA
Posts: 16
posted June 25, 2009 11:55 AM        
quote:
Not trying to be a dick but i don't understand how you are riding along at 55mph and don't see a piece of asphalt the size of 2 softballs before hitting it?


it was white concrete. the kind really bright sidewalks are made of. it was 1030 in the morning on a sunny day. i was even wearing a tinted shield and it was still bright as shit. yes i was in traffic. luckily everyone was paying enough attention to stop.
____________
Your 'Busa looks so much smaller in my rear view than i thought it would.

  Ignore this member   
clemson51087


Parking Attendant
Virginia Beach, VA
Posts: 16
posted June 25, 2009 11:58 AM        
bob those rims are beautiful. you should donate them to the broke ass sailor who wrecked his bike fund lol
____________
Your 'Busa looks so much smaller in my rear view than i thought it would.

  Ignore this member   
KawaBonzai


Zone Head
Leader of the Back.
Posts: 537
posted June 25, 2009 12:44 PM        
quote:
Last Tuesday i was riding along I64 westbound towards Richmond right before the Hampton roads bridge tunnel in Norfolk VA. when my front tire struck a large rock in the street. This rock was a piece of the asphalt that had broken up out of the interstate and was sitting on top of the highway. this rock was so large it bent my rim when i stuck it and sent me flying over the handle bars at 55 miles an hour. i have taken two safety courses one within the past two months plus i have been riding for over 8 years i am no newbie. this was simply caused by poor roadway maintenance as the roads around here are horrible to begin with. can i sue the company contracted to maintain this stretch of highway or am i simply SOL? She was a 2009 ZX14 Special Edition and i miss her dearly. i have extensive road rash on my lower back and my knees and have two fractured fingers even though i was wearing all of the proper gear.


Ditch the lawyer, file a claim, move on with life.

The burden of proof lies upon you, not the city/state. You have to prove that one entity or another is responsible for that rock being there. Good luck with that.

quote:
i have taken two safety courses one within the past two months plus i have been riding for over 8 years i am no newbie.


Get a refund for your last class, apparently it did not have any effect. You can not expect to go into a court and say ... I've taken 2 classes, plus this rock was SO large, and I'm not a newb. You'll get laughed at.

Shits gonna be on the road anyplace you ride. this is a simple case of you missing (or not missing) an obstacle on the road.

But go ahead and try the lawyer route if it costs you nothing. Probably he'll find an ATM video of Jose tossing boulders out fo his dumptruck thinking it'll improve his gas mileage.

____________
2009 ZX-14 Candy Lime Green
PC-III w/USB, Muzzys M14 + Carbon Oval + M10, BMC Race Filter, Flies Out, Buell Pegs, Heli Risers
www.TucsonSportRiders.com - Tucson's Premier SportRider Community

  Ignore this member    Click here to visit KawaBonzai's homepage. 
FastestBusaAround


Needs a life
I eat Fish...
Posts: 7889
posted June 25, 2009 02:44 PM        
ZXBOB - why does your bike have a ZX-11 insignia on it, or is it just the angle? Who ya trying to fool?
____________
FYYFF!!!

  Ignore this member    Click here to visit FastestBusaAround's homepage. 
Tool Man


Needs a job
Posts: 4493
posted June 25, 2009 03:18 PM        Edited By: Tool Man on 25 Jun 2009 23:19
quote:
ZXBOB - why does your bike have a ZX-11 insignia on it, or is it just the angle? Who ya trying to fool?


Stupid people

BTW...Sue the rock
Life sucks whem you least expect it.....pay and play
____________
The banks are failing..
The banks are failing...
Invest in Ammo

  Ignore this member   
zxbob


Pro
Posts: 1692
posted June 25, 2009 04:22 PM        
quote:
ZXBOB - why does your bike have a ZX-11 insignia on it, or is it just the angle? Who ya trying to fool?



You know Steve ....... there's many a funny story about my ZX-11

Once Beth and I road up to the Rock Store ~ people could'nt believe that she
was on a nitrous 14 and I only had an 1100 !

Another was someone ask me if my bike was imported, cause they had never seen
a ZX-11 before ..... I said "no shit"

Bob
____________
Good parts aint cheap and cheap parts aint good !

  Ignore this member   
GHOSTMAN


Expert Class
Posts: 456
posted June 25, 2009 06:53 PM        
Just curious Clemson. I'm familiar with the area, and I know how riding down there is. People are 3ft off your back wheel at 70mph and people are constantly slamming on brakes in front of you. Have to admit that the roads ARE crappy. Not making excuses, but not easy to maneuver with cages on your ass and your side and usually pushing in your lane.


____________
I'm There Whether You See Me Or Not.

  Ignore this member   
iflyems


Expert Class
Posts: 233
posted June 26, 2009 07:22 AM        
The simple answer to your question, "can I sue" is No. First, you must have a "responsible party". If it's the State, remember that State's, and the Federal government have sovereign immunity, so you need permission to sue them, which you won't get.
Next, you have to prove that the State had knowledge of the condition, or a reasonable suspicion that this condition existed.
Then you have to prove they were negligent in allowing this condition to occur.

It would cost you 10's of thousands of dollars in attorneys fee's and court costs to recover what?? In some states, there is even a cap on liability, so you may not even break even.

Best advice is just to be careful out there. These things happen, and it sucks when they do. How many people have had a window broken out by a rock thrown up from a passing car?? Whose fault is that? No ones.

I remember driving to work one day, and it cost me $383!!! That was to replace my windshield by a rock thrown up by a passing vehicle.

And, the road maintenance is only gonna get worse now that we have an Obamanation in the Presidency.

  Ignore this member   
clemson51087


Parking Attendant
Virginia Beach, VA
Posts: 16
posted June 27, 2009 09:46 PM        
I'm with you on the obamanation thing. but the state doesn't care for the roads anymore. they contract out to a company called vme so it looks like we're suing them. when the lady at dot told me they contract out i asked her what the fuck they even existed for anymore and i her response was "i honestly don't know sir"!

____________
Your 'Busa looks so much smaller in my rear view than i thought it would.

  Ignore this member   
FastestBusaAround


Needs a life
I eat Fish...
Posts: 7889
posted June 27, 2009 10:02 PM        
quote:
quote:
ZXBOB - why does your bike have a ZX-11 insignia on it, or is it just the angle? Who ya trying to fool?



You know Steve ....... there's many a funny story about my ZX-11

Once Beth and I road up to the Rock Store ~ people could'nt believe that she
was on a nitrous 14 and I only had an 1100 !

Another was someone ask me if my bike was imported, cause they had never seen
a ZX-11 before ..... I said "no shit"

Bob

So it really does say ZX11 -- cool. Guess you're trying to reel 'em in eh?
____________
FYYFF!!!

  Ignore this member    Click here to visit FastestBusaAround's homepage. 
zxbob


Pro
Posts: 1692
posted June 28, 2009 08:45 AM        
Im "fishing" ?


Bob
____________
Good parts aint cheap and cheap parts aint good !

  Ignore this member   
JDC


Zone Head
Posts: 570
posted June 28, 2009 09:51 AM        Edited By: JDC on 28 Jun 2009 18:18
You can sue for anything, but the important issue is can you prove you case, with evidence that the road was not maintained within "the standards of the industry" , beyond "a preponderance" (over 50% siding evidence and persuasion to you)...to a judge?

I think if the chunk that you hit was part of the original (un-maintained ?) road, you may have a chance...

but there is a portion of the law that also talks about "assumption of risk", and when dealing with anything. and also driving/riding, assumes the driver/rider is maintaining 'reasonable' vigilance and caution consistent to the road, driving/weather conditions.

I suspect you'd have a little homework/research to do before you can reasonably know the answer whether you'd have a good chance of meeting the requirement of "a preponderance" of evidence", eg be able to prove to a judge;

- That indeed the struck piece of material was a an original portion from the road you were operating on.

- What is the "'normal"/"customary" maintenance schedule for roads in your county/state, depending on who had jurisdiction of maintaining that road?

- Is that 'standard', the actual - real world road maint. history then compliant with the "standards of the industry" and or with the standards set forth in the county/state?

- Are your state/county maint. requirements consistent with the "standards of the industry" of other states and or Federal requirements, whatever applies?

- If the road was maintained under the 'standards", then often you might find Highway Patrol, or the like, removing obstacles from the road. They sure do in Calif. and that is part of their charge, to remove and report road hazards.

- Did the local law enforcement make any such report about this portion of the road to the responsible road maint dept? (that moves some or all of their liability, if they had any to begin with, to the maint/ depart in a law suit.. )

- If the road was maintained to 'standards' (County or State road Maint. Dept), then does the law enforcement authority over the road bear any liability/responsibility?

- Given the driving specifics how much liability might you share under the "assumption of risk" issue? Check your state driving handbook. I'd bet there is a clause in that booklet that talks about drivers always needing to maintain reasonable speed to the conditions, meaning the state (and a judge) would normally assume it is the drivers responsibility to be going slow enough to avoid 'reasonable' road hazards. I know, you did not predict that chunk in the road, but the judge will still apply part of that law as your portion of "assumption of risk'/responsibilities in this situation, and see how it fits. Your job is to convince him/her your porton of "assumption of risk" is as close to zero as you can.

etc.

In the end the judge has to weigh the issues above, as well as your portion of the liability (fault) of you hitting the object. The judge had to decide, from all the evidence given, decide the proportion of responsibility to you, Road Maint and or Law enforcement, etc. In the end you may get a favorable decision, but it will be proportioned on the amount of the total 'reasonable' claim the judge feels appropriate for the situation, minus you share of liability.

Given the amount of work for you to do, you'd have to weigh whether it is worth the time/money to make your 'evidence' discoveries, and see where they lead you with respect to having a reasonable (preponderance) case, or not.

  Ignore this member   
All times are America/Va [ This thread is 3 pages long: 1  2  3     Next» ] < Previous Thread     Next Thread >
BIKELAND > FORUMS > ZX-14.com > Thread: Can i sue for damages to my baby? NEW TOPIC NEW POLL POST REPLY

FEATURED NEWS   Bikeland News RSS Feed

HEADLINES   Bikeland News RSS Feed


Copyright 2000-2026 Bikeland Media
Please refer to our terms of service for further information
0.23870706558228 seconds processing time