posted May 25, 2004 06:15 AM
Brakeline Questions Here's a subject I don't know much about. The stock lines are rubber, possibly swelling under pressure and giving a softer feel than I like. I'm guessing it is the brakelines, so am willing to replace them.
I see two reputable manufacturers whose products I'm interested in: Galfer and Goodridge.
I see Goodridge makes several different types of lines, one of which K Bryant mentioned a short while ago with red-anodized fittings.
As near as I can tell, the red-anodized ones are 'dash-2' lines, which appear to have a smaller ID in the tubing and keeps pressures high for better lever feel. My first question is - the smaller ID is restricting the pressure that reaches the caliper, due to friction. Is this detrimental, or does it just mean increased lever effort with the smaller diameter?
Goodridge also make lower-spec braided stainless lines - would these be a better choice for me (not being a hardcore racer - yet?). These seem to come in colorless outer coat and a smoke outer coat.
Galfer makes smaller ID lines, too - but coat them inside with PTFE (Teflon(R)), and out. Presumably, the inner Teflon coat reduces the friction (and thus the lever effort) for the same pressure at the caliper, while keeping the better leverfeel.
Problem with the Galfers is - I don't really want straight fittings and the maintenance watch that goes with them. I'd much prefer banjo style.
Galfer apparently won't sell lines withgout fittings attached - so no do-it-yourself job.
Kerry had mentioned that Goodridge lines were available with fittings separately - but I don't know what's involved with mounting the fittings (imagine a crush block that is struck with a hammer to make the fitting crimp, but I don't know for sure). Cutting the lines I think is accomplished with a Dremel or other cut-off wheel. But where does one buy brakeline by the yard and the appropriate fittings, etc? And, is this a dramatically more expensive proposition?
So, for those who've built several brakesystems on different bikes, what's the smarter choice for an agressive street rider with trackday aspirations? Throw in that I ride probably 14,000 miles in a year (and don't get me started on radiator screens).
Needs a life
Full throttle!
Posts: One MEEEEEELLION
posted May 25, 2004 06:22 AM
I've had great success on the street and track with both Goodridge and Galfer lines. Outside of replacing the calipers and master cylinders with Brembos, I don't think anyone's brakes felt better than mine did with Goodridge -2 lines. So it really comes down to what you want. I like the looks of the Galfers this time, but might decide upon the Goodridges again next time.
____________
82 Gpz750, 84 Ninja 900, 2000 ZX12R (Muzzy Big Bore Kit), *another* 2000 ZX12R (Muzzy custom stroke crank 1341cc motor), 2004 ZZR1200, 2005 ZX10R, 2007 ZX14, 2008 Concours 14, 2014 Versys 650, 2014 Yamaha WR450F, 2015 Ninja H2
posted May 25, 2004 06:49 AM
Those are alot of good questions. I've often wondered about all that stuff myself, but been too lazy to research it. I just take it at face value that aftermarket lines work. Here's hoping we get some definitive answers.
____________
If you aren't an AMA member, you're part of the problem.
NESBA #209
posted May 25, 2004 06:58 AM
The stock rubber lines do swell . They swell quite a bit . On the 10R I "think" that they are using a small diameter master cylinder pushing less fliud to the calipers . This will give a relaxed/spongy braking effect . You have to use a LOT of the front brake lever to get any braking done . This is "possibly" due to the 10R and the ultra short wheelbase and people killing themselves . Just my guess of course . It is like Kawi is trying to limit the total braking power on the 10R . The front brakes are AWESOME in feel , you just keep pulling the lever . More lever , more braking action . But the front lacks any good bite on the rotors .
The smaller ID or inside diameter the line is , the less fluid volume is required to finally reach the pistons . Also the SS braided , kevlar or whatever lines do not allow any flex . That creates a much firmer lever feel . So you should get a firmer lever and have to pull less on the lever for improved braking . If I am incorrect in this fellas please correct me . Won't be the first time .
posted May 25, 2004 01:19 PM
Let's get a little theory out of the way here.
First, it takes a given amount of fluid to displace the pistons a certain distance. This is independent of line size or master cylinder size. Larger lines only increase total system volume, not the amount of fluid you have to send to the calipers.
Second, there are two major factors in the mushy feel at the lever. One is lines expanding and the other is something compressable in the system (namely, air). But no matter what, the piston in the master cylinder has to displace the volume necessary to get the pistons in the caliper to touch the rotors. After that you are just increasing pressure and overcoming inefficiences such as line expansion and caliper flex.
Now maybe smaller lines have less tendency to expand for a given material of construction, I don't know. I'm curious about what the brake manufacturers or pro teams would have to say.
____________
If you aren't an AMA member, you're part of the problem.
NESBA #209
posted May 25, 2004 02:22 PM
galfer makes banjo style lines for the zx-10. the lines others are referring to with the staight connector are the "superbike" lines. i have the banjo style lines, intend to install tonight. if i get it done, i'll let you know and send along a p/n. i'd give you the p/n now but the lines are sittin' in a friends shop.
____________
"My point? F#*k you! That's my point." - Bucky Katt
posted May 25, 2004 03:10 PM
-2's weigh a bit less than -3's. They also tend to be bare (not coated with plastic). Other than that they work about the same. The lever might be a bit harder with -2's, but the condition of the fluid is likely to have a bigger impact than the size of the line. ZX10R brakes are really good even with the stock lines. Until you get on them really hard and really late. Then you'll be wanting a bit more feedback. I think the link line is already braided.
posted May 25, 2004 05:13 PM
kz2zx - I should clarify - The Goodridge lines that I "make" my own kits from are complete finished lines. The lines are already made/finished with female screw- on fittings. I then buy the desired banjo fittings, bolts, crush washers. The only reason I like doing it this way is that I can choose the exact line length that "I" want. I also happen to like it more "modular" by being able to twist the lines around easier and/or remove them quicker/easier. Just personal preferance.
I was actually beginning to believe it was something like that. This is probably a more expensive route then.
So, given you have yoru plumbing preference, would you run one line from a double fitting at the master output to each caliper, or keep the Kawi routing?
I think I'll go with the Galfers if I can get them with banjos and teflon inside and out; and the Goodridge -3's if not.
If no one jumps to tell me 'No!', then this is how I'll play it -
posted May 25, 2004 05:45 PM
Edited By: k bryant on 25 May 2004 18:46
Cool. Definetly go with double fitting at the master output to each caliper. Much firmer feel. Be sure to use new crush washers. I personally prefer the aluminum (not copper). I feel they "crush" better. Good luck!
posted May 25, 2004 06:58 PM
galfer lines(fronts only) w/ banjo fittings Mfr # FK003D415. Double fitting at master cylinder w/ one line to each caliper. Feels good and firm, however, i only rode it 5 miles through the city. hope this helps. Oh, PTFE (teflon) type 62 inner, outerbraid stainless steel AISI 304 L. Thats what the package says. $85.00 at a normally overpriced dealer, but they were in stock and i wanted em NOW.
____________
"My point? F#*k you! That's my point." - Bucky Katt
posted May 26, 2004 05:24 PM
I too have the Galfer banjo fitted lines with a Dbl MC bleeder attached which aided in the bleed process greatly. The overall firmness in lever feel is noticable the first time you use them.
posted May 26, 2004 06:19 PM
indeed, BD. BTW, think you have spoken to a riding bud of mine...mike bash over at morse custum fiberglass.
____________
"My point? F#*k you! That's my point." - Bucky Katt
posted May 26, 2004 06:26 PM
Most Hydralic hose supply will have the raw material or can get it, You then can choose type and quality, They can make them to your specs or sell you the raw stuff, I have built quite a few lines over the years and prefer to make my own as the prebuilt units just don't fit as clean.
posted May 26, 2004 07:00 PM
TLR... most fab shops wont sell you the lines if you tell them its for brakes. (liability)
I always say they are for clutch lines. ____________
Official Charter Member of the RIDERS OF KAWASAKI MEMBERSHIP REVOCATION CLUB
Also a BadAss Internet Forum Moderator 4 Hire!! Come at me brah!
posted May 27, 2004 06:50 AM
I aint Skeeered! But I am a little nervous about some of the prefab units, And you are right! some shops won't fab brake lines, I usually buy the material and make it myself as I stated earlier for both quality and appearence.