entropy
Moderator
Posts: 8671
|
posted November 28, 2010 11:24 AM
"A Steady State test isn't exactly "natural" for most real world stuff, either, (except when topping out the bike > that's the 180 mph real world Steady State Test), where it's 100% equal and realistic loading - but, if a Steady State test is off, at all, it's a very small amount whereas Best Power on a dynojet vs the real world can be 5 mph "off", as stated above in someone's post."
yup, but...
This i KNOW from many, many dyno sessions, both Dynojet & FP, many Land speed passes, and something like 1500 1/4 passes, on heavily built motors.
1. A map generated USING STEPS on a FP dyno will be very close to the map needed at the track.
2. A map generated using Dynojet 5th gear pulls CAN be very close to that needed at the track IF THE DYNO OPERATOR IS TRACK SAVVY, like JohnnyCheese. If the tuner maps for max sweep hp, the map is junk, immediately needs more fuel at the track.
3. Sorry Marc, but i have to say it, I have found very little utility of the 4 gas capability of the FP. After looking at this and that gas number, I gave up and simply log AF when i tune on a FP. This is not for want of trying to utilize 4 gas readings. I have just under 60 (sixty) dyno sessions in the last 2.5 years on the FP as i developed my Zx12 motor. Yes, i know what i am supposed to look for...
____________
This moderator uses moderation in moderation
|
Ozonkiller
Expert Class
Posts: 350
|
posted November 29, 2010 07:56 PM
Wow, I was lambasted on the ZX14.com site for mentioning that the DJ numbers were about 15% inflated over the FP dyno numbers.
I was the dyno operator for Formula USA for a number of years and started out using the Dynojet and later used a Factory Pro with the help of Leigh Thomas. The dyno's were used to evaluate the bikes running in the horsepower limited classes. Because the racers results had to be validated at the dyno as they came off of the tracks, these racers and their tuners had unlimited access to the dyno through out the weekend
There were many weekends that I made no less than 1000 pulls and I am here to tell you that when it comes to consistency and repeatability, the Factory wins, hands down. That's not to say that the Dynojet sucks, it doesn't, but if you are looking for small changes, that repeatability counts.
Also without fail, I'd have the owner state "back home this bike made Blah Blah Blah" and I'd break out the calculator. Invariably, I'd take theri number and subtract 13% from their number and voila, same as the number I just ran on the FP dyno. (Or I would add 15% to the FP number...)
The biggest advantage to the Factory Pro is the customer service. Dynojet has none. More than once, Marc, Tom Q, and Lee has gotten my tit out of the wringer.
My 2 cents,
Tom
|
TRNorBRN6001
Needs a job
Posts: 2021
|
posted November 29, 2010 09:02 PM
FP vs. DJ, it's been a while since I have seen that.
Hey dickhead, lol, sorry I could not resist saying that, don't worry too much about HP numbers. As long as you have a good safe tune on it and your having fun.
Karl, good to hear about your experience with FP stuff. There is no doubt operater experience counts for a lot....................other wise I would have moved to Mo City and purchased an FP dyne and had it paid off with all them visits you made, LOL.
____________
TFA 200MPH CLUB MEMBER!
|
entropy
Moderator
Posts: 8671
|
posted November 29, 2010 09:49 PM
tom,
at what approx FP hp were you seeing the 13-15 hp difference?
just looking for another data point in "the more hp, the larger the % difference between FP & DJ"
____________
This moderator uses moderation in moderation
|
Ozonkiller
Expert Class
Posts: 350
|
posted November 29, 2010 10:06 PM
Not hp... percent
FP horsepower plus 15% equals DJ horsepower
or
DJ horsepower minus 13% equals FP horsepower
Example: 100 FP hp plus 15% equals 115 dj hp. 100 * 1.15 = 115
115 DJ hp minus 13% equals 100 FP hp. 115 * .87 = 100
It was pretty consistent everywhere from the 70 horsepower SV 650's that were common to the 135 hp 750's. The results were also consistent between the Factory dyno readings and Dynojet readings with my 14, back here in Phoenix.
Again, that was just my observation. Perhaps, your results may vary
Tom
|
entropy
Moderator
Posts: 8671
|
posted November 29, 2010 10:21 PM
Tom,
oops, that's what i meant, % difference.
what i have seen is an increase of % difference between DI & FP as hp goes up,..
my zx12 @ 200 FP hp showed about 20% higher on a DJ
i haven't put my Busa on a DJ yet, will do a FP/DJ comparo after the Dec tweak i am working on right now
thanks for the info.
Karl
____________
This moderator uses moderation in moderation
|
Ozonkiller
Expert Class
Posts: 350
|
posted November 29, 2010 10:32 PM
The thing that I have never had the opportunity to do is do a comparison between Factory dyno's with the same bike.
I have seen some pretty dramatic differences between Dynojet dynos.
The thing about Factory's dyno's is they make sense. There is a load cell that measures torque, just like a torque wrench. As anyone knows TQ times RPM divided by 5252 equals horsepower.
Nobody has been able to explain the math to me regarding a Dynojet's dyno.
That being said, I don't really care. I, personally only use a dyno as a comparitor. I make a change and the number goes up is good. I make a change and the number goes down is bad. This BS of dyno racing is just that... BS.
Good to chat with you Karl,
Tom
|
bbwatercool

Novice Class
Posts: 64
|
posted November 30, 2010 08:26 AM
ok, my question to the operators that have used both dyno's(FP and DJ), who has taken the hp that the FP dyno says a bike makes and ran it at a 1/4 mile drag strip to see if the dyno numbers are accurate..for example, a 600lb bike/rider runs 155 mph in the 1/4..with this math, there is no bs'ing the hp #'s...I do it all the time with my customers and the numbers add up every single time...there is no way that a 600 lb combo can run 155 mph and make 200 on one dyno and 185 on the other dyno(same bike,same day,etc.)..the laws of physics says it's not possible...
____________
Cycle Concepts
1625 Lynwood Dr
Lancaster,SC 29720
803.285.8093
Home of the Drag Pak Clutch Pak!!
|
entropy
Moderator
Posts: 8671
|
posted November 30, 2010 08:58 AM
Edited By: entropy on 30 Nov 2010 16:59
quote: ok, my question to the operators that have used both dyno's(FP and DJ), who has taken the hp that the FP dyno says a bike makes and ran it at a 1/4 mile drag strip to see if the dyno numbers are accurate..for example, a 600lb bike/rider runs 155 mph in the 1/4..with this math, there is no bs'ing the hp #'s...I do it all the time with my customers and the numbers add up every single time...there is no way that a 600 lb combo can run 155 mph and make 200 on one dyno and 185 on the other dyno(same bike,same day,etc.)..the laws of physics says it's not possible...
I hear you on this, and agree that the DJ hp numbers seem to work better with the 1/4mi mph calculators.
I think you'd need to go into the program that calculates 1/4mi mph from hp & weight and see what empirical assumptions are made.
____________
This moderator uses moderation in moderation
|
Shane661

Needs a life
Posts: 11494
|
posted November 30, 2010 10:00 AM
Edited By: Shane661 on 30 Nov 2010 18:01
The actual hp # is not that important, imo. The dyno is a tuning tool, and I only compare results from the same dyno. My local DJ200 produces repeatable results, which is adequate for my purposes.
Data logging, and mph at the track tell me what I need to know otherwise.
|
mathews
Expert Class
Posts: 425
|
posted November 30, 2010 10:13 AM
quote: The actual hp # is not that important, imo. The dyno is a tuning tool, and I only compare results from the same dyno. My local DJ200 produces repeatable results, which is adequate for my purposes.
Data logging, and mph at the track tell me what I need to know otherwise.
X1000000
|
|
|
|
|