HOME ARTICLES JOIN GALLERY STORE SPONSORS MARKETPLACE CONTACT US  
Register | FAQ | Search | Memberlist
Username:    Password:       Forgot your password?
BIKELAND > FORUMS > ZX12R ZONE.com > Thread: Do Dyno's Kill Engines..... NEW TOPIC NEW POLL POST REPLY
MadMike


Moderator
FEAR THE BLACK FLAG!!!!!!!!
Posts: 6579
posted May 25, 2004 06:55 AM        
I understand someone who, knows what they are doing such as Muzzys race shop and KB's dyno, not having problems but I actually like this discussion, I honestly believe RA has a point, and instead of blaming the dyno's though why don't we see "Why" it happened, people who have lost a motor on the dyno, tell us about it, how many pulls? how hot? were there other issues? What parts failed? were you experimenting say with lots of nitrous, or High Comp?
Mad Mike
____________
200-MPH CLUB MEMBER!

  Ignore this member    Click here to visit MadMike's homepage. 
Tearinitup


Expert Class
VP Code Monkey
Posts: 298
posted May 25, 2004 07:09 AM        Edited By: Tearinitup on 25 May 2004 08:13
quote:
I will make a bold statement,,,,,ALL engines will fail with less than 50 dyno miles.


My 00 12 was the test mule that did all the testing for the original PCIII. Prior to me buying it it had never seen a street mile and I bought it with over 4000 dyno miles. Sorry to say... Operators kill bikes.

Plus... The drum on the dyno is lighter than your bike actually providing LESS load than the street.

  Ignore this member   
Ra12r


Zone Head
Posts: 919
posted May 25, 2004 11:07 AM        
Okay,,,,,,,Tearinitup wasn't toreup on the dyno! hahahahaha So, that brings up a good counter example. I must agree with Mike about finding out more info.

Secondly I am not actually thinking about NOS or TURBO test bikes. Especially NOS bikes as it is just a matter of time with those. Will the guys that had a motor die on a dyno please comment with what happened inside the engine after it blew up.


Plus... The drum on the dyno is lighter than your bike actually providing LESS load than the street.
My question for our physics teacher, BEANSBASTER sp? Which has more inertia and resistance,,,,,,1) a 600lbs weight on two wheels accelerating linearly or 2) a fixed 600lbs rotational weight centrifugally accelerating moving around an axis??

____________
All must bow to the "Ra Supremecy"...

  Ignore this member   
your car is slow


Needs a job
Fuck Nitrous...Got Boost?
Posts: 4089
posted May 25, 2004 11:34 AM        
I cant see how the bike..or the motor..would know the difference between a 5 gear pull on a dyno..and a 5 gear 1/4 mile run.

other than the G forces exerted on the bike and its internal components (oil included)...it should be exactly the same as far as the motor is concerned...sure it thinks the bike is a tad lighter (as im assuming it takes less power to roll that drum at 150mph than it does to push the bike through the air at 150)...is there perhaps some oil return design that only works under accelleration? Meaning when the bike is accellerating rapidly..but not going anywhere (on a dyno) the oil doesnt flow like it normally would if the bike was actually accellerating? If so..this would most certainly be a risk as the oil pressure would be much lower..or the volume would be less..or perhaps oil isnt getting to a particular component in the motor that it normally would under WFO accelleration.

Who knows
____________
Do not taunt happy fun ball!

  Ignore this member    Click here to send Your Car Is Slow an AIM message. 
slug


Pro
Out in search of my mind...
Posts: 1433
posted May 25, 2004 02:00 PM        
cooling issue theory expanded:

an issue with ICE cooling is that the oil is a significant part of the cooling of the internals of the engine that DON'T see water cooling via cooling passages. (pistons, crankshaft, camshafts, transmission parts, etc)

many bikes do have water/oil coolers, but the flow through those is miniscule compared to what heat the oil is capable of holding

the entire engine outside is part of the cooling system, and the engine itself being forced through air helps keep the oil cooler.

when sitting still, oil temps will rise quickly. and since they don't impact directly things that the water hits, it isn't going to be a linear response between the oil temp and water temp.

sooo parts of the engine that are oil cooled only WILL show a significant rise in temperature. since the only way these parts can shed heat is via the oil splash or via conduction and radiation to other parts inside engine, they WILL have a much higher than normal temperature. the oil will be much thinner, and perhaps unable at lower engine RPM (and thus system oil pressure due to viscosity changes) to provide the film strength required to maintain proper non-metalic contact. once you start to dirty up bearing surfaces, perhaps a small galled part that is proud of the surface slightly, you disrupt even the high-rpm and high pressure oil film formation. and this may explain higher bearing failure rate while sitting still on dyno, and why they don't fail in stop & go traffic. (how often in s&g traffic do you have opportunity to go from stopped to WOT before riding a distance?)

the water temperature may reach the normal fan switch, and may act to reduce engine temperature AS INDICATED by the water temperature, but the engine itself is still sitting not moving. the oil will notbe cooled significantly by the coolant in this situation, as it has lost all OTHER forms of cooling, other than radiation from the engine itself. (though sitting still it has header heat on outside to contend with as well)

as a bit of information that i have that may help a bit with this: when riding my bikein s&g traffic, the median temperature never falls, it always rises.

the longer the bike sits still, the less often the fan is able to kick the water temperature back down to the fan cutoff temp. the first cycle, coolant temperature pretty much drops in a minute or so to 80. then fan kicks off and it rises back to 105. after a while, it will take several minutes to drop to 80, or even longer, it just stays stable at 100 or so.

if i know i am going to be in slow traffic, i turn fan on manually (relay and switch in parallel with the thermal switch) when i stop the temperature will stay around 80 for a few minutes, and then it will slowly start to climb, even with fan on.


these are just some basic, non-scientific observations, and the conclusion that i have made based on them.

also do we have any data on the type of oils being run, whether synthetic or otherwise? new or old? that could be important information. i always take bike for dyno runs on fresh oil.

------------------

as for rev limiter issue, i don't think hitting rev limiter itself is the problem, the rev limiter won't harm the engine. BUT the limiter is above the engine's maximum design rev ceiling, and meant to stop engine speed from going beyond the maximum over-stress limits built in.

another point, running on rev limiter will dump a lot of unburnt fuel, and may end up causing damage to exhaust components(BOOM!!). but the unburnt fuel will help to cool the combustion chamber ;P

just some thoughts
and a theory of mine, that may or may not have any basis in the real world....

anyone else care to elaborate on my oil vs water cooling systems ideas? or do i get the "crackpot of the day" award?

  Ignore this member    Click here to send Slug an ICQ message. Click here to add 1734970 to your ICQ list. Click here to visit Slug's homepage. Click here to send Slug an AIM message. 
Tearinitup


Expert Class
VP Code Monkey
Posts: 298
posted May 25, 2004 02:21 PM        Edited By: Tearinitup on 25 May 2004 15:23
The ummm.... "mass equivilent" for a dyno is about 400 lbs. Not talking mass of the drum or rotational inertia. The drum simulates about 400 lbs in linear motion. So it is (by design) a bit lighter than most bikes with riders.

Also... Our R&D dyno room has a pretty nice cooling setup. We have the standard cooling fans plus a 20+ hp "wind" motor to help it out. So that might have helped the longevity of my bike.

  Ignore this member   
Ra12r


Zone Head
Posts: 919
posted May 25, 2004 06:30 PM        
YCIS,,,,,,that oil return design without acceleration is an interesting thought indeed.

Slug, i do agree that at some internal oil temperature, the thickness of the oil layer falls "below" the neccessary need to "float" the rods or main journals. However, i kinda feel that sitting in traffic would cause motor failure more often, except it is not at 11,000 rpms under stress either.

hmmmm.....400lbs linear weight is lighter, but is that what the dyno's are operated at especially if torque is being calculated? When does an operator also include drum braking during a pull?
____________
All must bow to the "Ra Supremecy"...

  Ignore this member   
slug


Pro
Out in search of my mind...
Posts: 1433
posted May 25, 2004 07:20 PM        
yeh that's my point in the traffic thing, hardly ever is there a chance to GET the engine to max power output and really stress the engine guts at those temps. once you've gotten enough speed up to have opening for more power, it's cooled sufficiently to be safe.

again just a theory, but one that seems to stand up to observed behavior of my machine. (the temperature thing,not the failure)

i've had mine on dyno at 36000 miles, and it survived fine. still burns no oil, OEM clutch, etc etc. (almost 48k on it now)

but it was only there for a HP/torque/A/F checkup so only a few runs and it was all over

somewhere i have 4 sets of dyno sheets, prolly 15-20 pulls total

anyway i really don't know that there CAN be any correlation made, it seems that even racers have engine failures at most inopportune times. (KR Jr. a few years back anyone?)

  Ignore this member    Click here to send Slug an ICQ message. Click here to add 1734970 to your ICQ list. Click here to visit Slug's homepage. Click here to send Slug an AIM message. 
k bryant


Needs a job
Sponsor
Posts: 2911
posted May 25, 2004 08:38 PM        Edited By: k bryant on 25 May 2004 21:44
ra12r - The "suspect" engine had a high mileage lower end from a full Daytona week with a privateer. It had a fresh top with very high lift cams (relieved the tappet bores), about 30 thou piston pocket to valve clearance, and very tight lobe centers. We never did figure out what let go first, because the dyno room caught on fire when one rod came through the front of the case and lodged in the header. The other rod came out the back. Oil, gas and some hair from my leg started burning all over the place. We advised against it, but the "not pissed off at all racer" wanted to do it anyway. It was a real mess and I must admit, it scared the piss out of me (Dynojet, so I'm sitting right on top of the SOB) So.... going by what he was telling us prior to running it, that's why I say it was "suspect".

Slug - Not sure about the pro/con of rev-limiter. It's rare to finish a run until we hit it. So in-other-words, we always bounce off it. Essentially every time. Haven't seen any issues.

  Ignore this member    Click here to visit K Bryant's homepage. 
MadMike


Moderator
FEAR THE BLACK FLAG!!!!!!!!
Posts: 6579
posted May 26, 2004 04:09 AM        
LMAO... dude glad you were ok... you have that one on video???
____________
200-MPH CLUB MEMBER!

  Ignore this member    Click here to visit MadMike's homepage. 
johnnycheese


Pro
Posts: 1008
posted May 26, 2004 04:45 AM        
quote:

I will make a bold statement,,,,,ALL engines will fail with less than 50 dyno miles.



due to I will have to make you see the light......
Kawasaki Mean Streak approx. 12K on the clock owner complains of oil consumption .5qt. in 200 miles. I STRAP it down on the dyno, rigg it up to hold 3K on the tach and apply a 20% brake load for guess how long?????


410 miles it ending up drinking about 460cc of oil Kawaski warrantied the rings that were toast. when they tore it down no other wear items found. customer has new piston and rings and has put anothr 5K on it so far.
It goes back to engine builder and operator no the machine itself.
Take a quess how many times the cooling fan came on on the Mean Streak????????

ZERO
Your theory is flawed and you nothing to back it. just drop it.
or I will be force to post more proof that you are WRONG
____________
Builder and tuner of some of the fastest N.A. and P/A Hayabusas and ZX12 /14 in Texas

  Ignore this member   
Tearinitup


Expert Class
VP Code Monkey
Posts: 298
posted May 26, 2004 07:22 AM        
KB- Holy shit. Glad to hear you are ok.

Slug- I always hit the Rev Limiter also.

This turned into a great thread lots of people actually discussing a solution to a possible problem with very little mud slinging.

  Ignore this member   
MadMike


Moderator
FEAR THE BLACK FLAG!!!!!!!!
Posts: 6579
posted May 26, 2004 08:53 AM        
JC, dude count to 10.... LOL.... We need some people who have had failures to post on here? how about the one's that did fail? Kevin, how about your failures? maybe it is all builder, but I also think it could be operator....
____________
200-MPH CLUB MEMBER!

  Ignore this member    Click here to visit MadMike's homepage. 
psycho1122


Pro
Posts: 1608
posted May 26, 2004 08:58 AM        
Hip! Hip! HORRAY! JC!


____________
You say PSYCHO like it's a BAD thing!!

  Ignore this member   
johnnycheese


Pro
Posts: 1008
posted May 26, 2004 09:33 AM        
quote:
JC, dude count to 10.... LOL.... We need some people who have had failures to post on here? how about the one's that did fail? Kevin, how about your failures? maybe it is all builder, but I also think it could be operator....
uno dos tres.......dez
____________
Builder and tuner of some of the fastest N.A. and P/A Hayabusas and ZX12 /14 in Texas

  Ignore this member   
MadMike


Moderator
FEAR THE BLACK FLAG!!!!!!!!
Posts: 6579
posted May 26, 2004 10:24 AM        
cervaca,, that is a # right...........
____________
200-MPH CLUB MEMBER!

  Ignore this member    Click here to visit MadMike's homepage. 
slug


Pro
Out in search of my mind...
Posts: 1433
posted May 26, 2004 01:08 PM        
my point wasn't that the rev limiter was bad, just that it prevents getting OUT Of the design limits

hitting it is one thing, but living on it i think is quite another thing entirely.

  Ignore this member    Click here to send Slug an ICQ message. Click here to add 1734970 to your ICQ list. Click here to visit Slug's homepage. Click here to send Slug an AIM message. 
k bryant


Needs a job
Sponsor
Posts: 2911
posted May 26, 2004 01:29 PM        
I wish I had a video of it. It's crystal clear in my head like it happened yesterday... What was kinda "funny", was that it didn't make the noise I expected. I was kinda a "puff" sound, then everything seem to ignite off the heat from the red-hot header pipes. We got everything under control fairly quickly. But like I said, what a mess it made (including my shorts...).
  Ignore this member    Click here to visit K Bryant's homepage. 
Outlaw1


Zone Head
Posts: 803
posted June 01, 2004 01:36 PM        
I believe a dyno is no different than a drag strip, If there is a flaw in the engine it may be exposed during dyno run or a 1/4 mile run. No fault of dyno just a flaw in the engine.

Anything is subject to flaws, If I had a flaw in my engine, Like a partial block on an oil passage to bearing, I'd much rather it go boom on dyno than on the strip/road/maxton.

Disclaimer your resuilts may vary.
____________
Lead, Follow, Or get the hell outta the way.

  Ignore this member   
Outlaw1


Zone Head
Posts: 803
posted June 01, 2004 01:45 PM        
I also believe in theory of bad operators. I found one of them.

He placed fans pointed to the side of my engine with cowls on, not towards the front of the radator And he pulled it five times. I went and looked at temp gauge and it was blinking and radator fill bottle sight glass, I could see boiling of antifreeze. I cussed him hard and long and continued on his boss and then the owner of the shop.

Some folks should not be operators of dynos. I agree with that theory also.

  Ignore this member   
worm~hole


Needs a life
Miles to go before I sleep....
Posts: 10623
posted June 01, 2004 02:17 PM        
quote:
He placed fans pointed to the side of my engine with cowls on, not towards the front of the radator And he pulled it five times.


...maybe he wanted the fan to blow on him to show you what a cool dyno operator he was...I've never seen that side-blow fan placement....always from the front pointed AT the radiator...
____________
“We sleep safe in our beds because rough men
stand ready in the night to visit violence on those
who would do us harm.”

-George Orwell

  Ignore this member   
Outlaw1


Zone Head
Posts: 803
posted June 02, 2004 04:36 AM        
It was a Honda Zuk Harley shop wormhole. I think the numb nut operator thought he was working on a Harley, Which you do place fans on the side Needless to say they the shop have not seen a dollar of mine since.

I was a cunt hair from kicking his ass on the spot. But the thought of jail detoured me from opening a can of whoop ass on him.
____________
Lead, Follow, Or get the hell outta the way.

  Ignore this member   
All times are America/Va [ This thread is 2 pages long: 1  2   ] < Previous Thread     Next Thread >
BIKELAND > FORUMS > ZX12R ZONE.com > Thread: Do Dyno\'s Kill Engines..... NEW TOPIC NEW POLL POST REPLY

FEATURED NEWS   Bikeland News RSS Feed

HEADLINES   Bikeland News RSS Feed


Copyright 2000-2026 Bikeland Media
Please refer to our terms of service for further information
0.28802585601807 seconds processing time