HOME ARTICLES JOIN GALLERY STORE SPONSORS MARKETPLACE CONTACT US  
Register | FAQ | Search | Memberlist
Username:    Password:       Forgot your password?
BIKELAND > FORUMS > ZX10R ZONE.com > Thread: Getting ticked at magazine tests (rant - long) NEW TOPIC NEW POLL POST REPLY
Jammer


Novice Class
Posts: 93
posted April 30, 2004 01:25 PM        
Getting ticked at magazine tests (rant - long)

Alright, I'm getting pissed off. I do appreciate the positive reports the magazines are giving, however, I'm getting ticked at the "new" testing criteria. As a loyal Kawi fan, I've had to put up with the last few years of tests where the ZX9 was always on the bottom of the heap because it was "too road oriented" compared to the other liter-class bikes. In fact, it almost never had the slowest lap time around a track, usually beating the Honda or the Yamaha or both. But, it was "harder to ride around the track" compared to the others, even though it posted a faster time. Now that we have the ZX10R, perhaps the most track-focussed of the bunch, the rules seem to have changed. Now their saying that it's maybe the most intense, but after all "these are still streetbikes" and have to be comfortable in the real world, being the best on the track is good, but not enough - it has to be a comfortable streetbike. Where was this opinion the last few years when the ZX9 was the best "streetbike?" So, the rules have changed, apparently. It seems to be an anti-Kawasaki crusade. Just when Kawi beats the others at their own game - primarily Honda and Yamaha whom the excuses have had to be made for - OK, really primarily Honda - they have to change the rules to make the other brands beat Kawasaki. I've always believed that journalists have been objective, honest, credible, but I'm starting to change my mind. Last month's editorial in Motorcyclist, Mitch Boehm (I am aware of all of the comments about the magazine & him in particular, & I have been a supporter of him regardless), stated that while the Honda may be lower on power, heavier, we have to keep in mind that it's still a "streetbike" after all. And, even the British have gone there, the latest Fast Bikes (I think) at the store today had a report on the ZX10 & the R1, and concluded that the ZX may be a great track bike, but loses out in the real world, on the street, because of it's extreme focus. I was so pissed I didn't buy the mag.
Who changed the rules? When?
They can all piss off - the ZX10 is the best.

There, I feel better now.
Thanks for listening.

  Ignore this member   
zeta xray


Expert Class
Posts: 416
posted April 30, 2004 01:57 PM        
I have always felt that most of the magazine writers have their own agenda and I have never taken what they say at full face value. I apply my own (perhaps distorted?) filters to everything they say. When they say brand "x" now has a steering damper but it needs to have more damping, I read that the bike is a wobbly bitch and they are really glad it has a steering damper, for example. Or when they justify a bike weighing more, they are showing their prejudice towards that brand. Every one has brand prejudice, myself included. I just don't have the opportunity to reach as many readers as the guys that work for the magazines. Long ago, I figured out that their opinion had no more value than mine. There is no doubt that the ZX10 has raised the bar when it comes to liter bike performance. I am glad I bought one. Maybe some of those wuss magazines writers have seen the future and they are afraid. I can tell you that my ZX10 is a better street bike than my '98 R1 and a hell of a lot better track bike.
  Ignore this member   
matt sterbator


Pro
Hiding in the bushes
Posts: 1367
posted April 30, 2004 02:31 PM        
Don't lose any sleep over magazine reviews, and don't buy them to reaffirm your purchase. All that matters is what YOU think of the bike.
____________
Some day, you're going to run out of some days

  Ignore this member    Click here to visit Matt Sterbator's homepage. 
guzmanx-zx10r


Expert Class
2005 zx10r
Posts: 236
posted April 30, 2004 02:36 PM        
I agree with that good point matt
  Ignore this member    Click here to send guzmanx-ZX10R an AIM message. 
Jammer


Novice Class
Posts: 93
posted April 30, 2004 02:55 PM        
I agree with everything you all say. I take everyting with a grain of salt, etc. If I listened to them, I wouldn't be a Kawi fan. It just irks me that they are always changing the rules & criteria.
  Ignore this member   
burgerking


Expert Class
Posts: 193
posted May 01, 2004 07:41 AM        
It was nice to read those tests during the waiting period (and winter) now spring and my 10R have arrived I simply don't give a fcuk what they say
I am deeply in love with my 10R it goes like snot, handles like nothing I've ever ridden before. Suspension is a bit stiff, haven't done any fine tuning. Simply put: the 10R is fantastic, great, brilliant and what the rest of the world think including magazine testers is as of now totally irrelevant to me.

  Ignore this member   
kz2zx


Pro
Nobody in Particular
Posts: 1166
posted May 01, 2004 08:40 AM        
I concur with ^ burgerking


  Ignore this member   
Zed


Expert Class
Posts: 118
posted May 01, 2004 10:06 AM        
There will be a lot of people who will miss out on this great bike, if they are swayed by what's written in the UK mags. Had a quick read of one this morning, whilst on the obligatory family shopping trip. It was a comparison of the 04 models. One journo "didn't want to ride the 10R", as he had already had his fill on it a week previous. That immediately gave bad vibes to the journo he was talking to, who then proceded to pick holes... At that point I placed the mag back down on the shelf - I didn't have my glasses with me anyway... Perhaps they were talking about the R1 and not the 10R. It's the eyes, you see...

Anyway, like you guys, I love the 10. My only gripe thus far is not about the suspension, or the brakes, or the willpower testing (teasing) break-in. It's actually the angle that the grips are at. I don't mind leaning forward at all, but those grips give me wrist-ache, because of angle they are at to the forks. Nice for the track. Crap for me on the road during break-in.

Still, I'm at 442miles now, preparing for stage 2 squirting. Nice.


____________
Live long, and Faster

  Ignore this member   
dnwhoop02


Expert Class
Posts: 204
posted May 03, 2004 05:55 AM        Edited By: dnwhoop02 on 3 May 2004 06:55
I haven't read any of the UK mags, but as for CycleWorld, they seem to take a pretty objective look at the '04 liter bikes, judging on 5 categories (road course, street riding, mechanical, drag strip, racing). Since there were 5 categories and 4 bikes, the one that won 2 of the categories was crowned the winner. In the end, the 10R came out on top where it belongs, winning the "street" and "drag strip" categories with each of the other bikes winning one of the remaining categories. However, I suspect that lack of riding skill kept it from achieving the fastest lap times around the road course... oh well. It was about a second behind the GSXR... pretty disappointing, but I guess I'll keep my 10R and not trade it in for a G1K .
____________
David
'04 ZX-10R
'00 SV650

  Ignore this member    Click here to send dnwhoop02 an AIM message. 
Ghostrider32


Parking Attendant
Posts: 2
posted May 03, 2004 06:53 AM        
The bike mags bias doesn't stop with the street bikes, it carries over to the dirt bikes as well. I read a review on the 04 KX250 and basically the mag called it trash. Oh sure, like one single editor can ride it to it's full potential. If they could, they'd be out there racing against Bubba Stewart for 1 or 2 million a year.

By the way, Ima gonna get me one of those 10r's. Waiting for the '05's to come out and then I'm gonna trade my '03 FZ1 in. Yeehaw, can't wait. Then I get to listen to the Ducati dude at work tell me how Kawi has never won a championship, yada yada yada, and everything else. He's even gone so far as to tell me that the 10r is to much for me to handle. I guess he would know judging by all the trophies in his den. LOL. The real deal is that he's mad that no one cares that he ended up spending $23,000 on his 999 (counting mods and all) and pretty much any of the '04 liter bikes will smoke his butt for $11,000. Just petty jealousy.

My .02 worth.

  Ignore this member   
salsa1


Needs a life
Posts: 5971
posted May 03, 2004 12:40 PM        
Biggest flaw of ZX-10R in my expert opinion (haha) is it simply needs a steering damper. Can you imagne what the comparo tests done would have been like with a scotts steering damper on the ZX-10R??

Still it is ranking very high in most rteviews Ihave seen and if you own one you can make your own review; Your review is the one that really matters. We are all biased to some degree.

I understand the lack of fairness in magazines. Readers do not have the means to compare all four Jap manufacturers in a given class. But we can compare all comparo reviews and whos lying or far biased will show.

Just a few thoughts.

Be happy; ZX-10R is a really great bike. Nice sport touring machine too.
I have put close to 200 miles in one run with little aches to speak of; really not expected to be this good. I am very Happy with ZX-10R might make it my only bike as I do not cruise 500+ mile trips and sell my ZX-11....

____________
Salsa1

  Ignore this member   
DKET


Expert Class
Posts: 189
posted May 03, 2004 01:31 PM        
I totally agree Jammer . Like you said all the mags rate the bikes on TRACK performance . Nothing hardly ever mentioned about the 99% of the bikes and street riding till now . Maybe Kawi forgot to send in their mag bribe money for 2004 . I know the other 3 makes send in a ton .

I stopped subscribing a long time ago to Cycle World and the others . When is the last time you ever saw a pipe or a tire test like the euro mags do ? Not to mention the breastesesses they gracefully display .

  Ignore this member   
johnnyboy


Expert Class
Posts: 315
posted May 03, 2004 01:37 PM        
Man, I hope you never change women... SOme of the girls out there are harsh.

  Ignore this member   
redelk


Moderator
Please... speak to the hand.
Posts: 3212
posted May 03, 2004 04:27 PM        
I have always said... I don't ride "magazines". I ride motorcycles. There are a few things I personally feel that makes it easy for me to say this.

1. Reviews and comparisons are usually "subjective", not "objective". This is not to fault the article. Its understood that "numbers" alone do not give a complete picture.

2. Numbers are just that... numbers. Doesn't matter if it's from a dyno or the Streets of of Willow Springs. No two dyno numbers are ever the same and I know I'd never see anything close to the lap times posted for the article. The minor differences (even if it was a full second) are way beyond my skills, thus I wouldn't be able to know the difference.

3. Most importantly, those that write these reviews and comparisons are not... me. It doesn't matter which one they say feels best on the street or track. That it because it is what THEY say feels best on the street or track... to THEM! Not me. They don't ride like I do (they are far better skilled), they don't ride where I ride (their tracks and roads are usually far smoother surfaces than mine) and they don't share half of the expectations and desires of what a motorcycle is or does, that I do.

So, having said that, though they are motorcyclists like myself, their opinions carry just a little more, but not much more, weight than that of my mother's when it comes to what bike suits me best. They are both equally subjective. THe only difference is that the magazines talk about lap times and my mother talks about the color.
____________
There are only three sports: bullfighting, motor racing, and mountaineering; all the rest are merely games.
-Ernest Hemingway

  Ignore this member    Click here to visit redelk's homepage. 
DB


Pro
Posts: 1932
posted May 04, 2004 12:01 AM        
LOL - good points Sherm.

Even if you look at the end of these tests in the mags you'll see that each test rider may have their own opinion of what is best. Like Sherm said, these are only numbers and opinions on what fits them best.
____________
Dan
04 ZX10r (Track only)
08 Concours14

  Ignore this member   
frEEk


Administrator
ummm... yeah
Posts: 9660
posted May 04, 2004 08:11 AM        
you are of course absolutely correct redelk, but at the same time, magazine tests are the best chance most of us have to compare the options available to us. i think the majority of people dont get a chance to test ride all the bikes before buying, and if you do, it's gonna be for half an hour or less, which often doesnt tell u what u need to know. plus, they are professional motorcycle journalists and we pay for their information (well, those that buy the magazine do), so i think it's only fair to expect a useful review. i suppose if you average all teh reviews out, u'll prolly get a pretty fair impression of the bike. i guess the way i look at it is that the magazines can't really tell you which bike is best for you, but they CAN tell you if the bikes have any particularly obvious shortfalls. if you can find a reviewer whose opinion of ergos matches your own, stick with that reviewer as ergos seem to produce the wildest range of scores.
  Ignore this member    Click here to visit frEEk's homepage. 
beansbaxter


Needs a life
Posts: 5911
posted May 04, 2004 09:36 AM        
I agree with the overall average of reviews, because ZHool is the only guy I knew that had every bike to ride at his disposal whenever he wanted to.
  Ignore this member    Click here to visit beansbaxter's homepage. 
Erich


Expert Class
Posts: 131
posted May 04, 2004 09:51 AM        
Well said freek. That is my take exactly. The choices this year are so good they could make anyones head spin. More information is never a bad thing.

The dynamic with the mags seems to be if you get the opinion you hoped for, then they are golden, if not, they are useless rags.

I will say that I have found some of the reviews are not 100% accurate with the bikes I have gotten, but the 'flavor' and general feel is close.


  Ignore this member   
All times are America/Va < Previous Thread     Next Thread >
BIKELAND > FORUMS > ZX10R ZONE.com > Thread: Getting ticked at magazine tests (rant - long) NEW TOPIC NEW POLL POST REPLY

FEATURED NEWS   Bikeland News RSS Feed

HEADLINES   Bikeland News RSS Feed


Copyright 2000-2026 Bikeland Media
Please refer to our terms of service for further information
0.31055402755737 seconds processing time