trenace

Needs a job
Posts: 3056
|
posted August 25, 2005 10:47 PM
Well, I will see if I can get around in the next week or two to doing the hotplate viscosity experiment with whatever straight-weight and multigrade same-brand combo I can find at the Wal-Mart.
If at 100 C the straight 40 flows through the same opening no slower than the 10W-40, then the previous observation at least does not hold for the brand now being tested. (It is possible that the previous observation and Jere's observation might have been with oils not meeting their nominal specification.) On the other hand, if the 40 weight flows slower, that will back up that this at least sometimes happens, that the straight oil even when hot is thicker than the corresponding multigrade with the same upper value.
|
tuusinii

Pro
Posts: 1031
|
posted August 26, 2005 12:52 AM
If You would want to do the test so that it should be done - there shouldn't be jus a hole but a thin tube where the oil goes trough. That would also be more realistic because there isin't that much holes in the engine as there are tubes. It could also be quite easy to find the size of the tube that should be used.
I'd say that depending on the oils the straight 40 can be either thicker or thinner depending about the labels because those SAE weigths leave some tolerance.
And when You are allready there doing maybe You could also do the same test in different temperatures also.
|
slug

Pro
Out in search of my mind...
Posts: 1433
|
posted August 26, 2005 02:50 AM
just to make sure that there is no question, the ONLY thing that maintains the oil film that protects your crank & rod bearings IS oil pressure.
without the pressure, the film will not be storng enough to withstand the pressure pulses from the combustion process. while there is some wedge formation just due to shaft rotation, once that nice power pulse hits it's all over.
under pressure the oil is a non-compressible fluid, and the leading edge oil film/wedge will keep the metal parts from touching. the trailing edge of the wedge runs out through the 'drain' which, depending on the engine design, goes to other oil-lubricated items, or back to the sump.
having a 'sticky' oil won't help here, since the engine pressure forces the contact.
if i were you i would install an oil pressure guage to make sure that pressure isn' t falling
|
psycho1122

Pro
Posts: 1608
|
posted August 26, 2005 08:05 AM
Guage is a definately better than the "It's Too Late Red Lite"
____________
You say PSYCHO like it's a BAD thing!!
|
trenace

Needs a job
Posts: 3056
|
posted August 26, 2005 11:01 AM
Edited By: trenace on 26 Aug 2005 12:03
I have to disagree, Slug.
The pressure from the oil pump is absolutely insignificant in compared to the pressures generated by combustion. The "push" that pressure is exerting in the opposite direction is relatively almost nothing.
Rather, what maintains the oil film despite being continually out the sides of the bearings, is FLOW.
Yes, you don't get flow without pressure, but the point is that it's not the pressure being applied to the oil film that matters, it's the existence of the oil film.
A thicker oil will take longer to be lost (leak out) from a bearing after loss of flow than will a thinner oil.
|
238mph

Pro
Posts: 1145
|
posted August 26, 2005 02:04 PM
quote: I have to disagree, Slug.
The pressure from the oil pump is absolutely insignificant in compared to the pressures generated by combustion. The "push" that pressure is exerting in the opposite direction is relatively almost nothing.
Rather, what maintains the oil film despite being continually out the sides of the bearings, is FLOW.
Yes, you don't get flow without pressure, but the point is that it's not the pressure being applied to the oil film that matters, it's the existence of the oil film.
A thicker oil will take longer to be lost (leak out) from a bearing after loss of flow than will a thinner oil.
Right on... and sticky adds in the oil prevent it from rinsing off so quickly.
Tests have shown that many motors can run HOURS with no oil presssure as long as
they had some of these additives in the oil prior to draining it..
|
trenace

Needs a job
Posts: 3056
|
posted August 26, 2005 03:21 PM
Actually I have to disagree with myself on a minor point in the above: actually the pressure exerted "in the opposite direction" approaches ZERO as the pressure is coming from all sides of the bearing. So it neither tends to push up or down.
If it were a sealed hydraulic system it would be exactly zero, as the pressure would be equal at all points, 360 degrees, around the bearing. Since there is loss of fluid, in actuality pressure is likely a little less 180 degrees from the oil passage, so there may be a slight force in that direction. That slight force would be the "relatively almost nothing" force in counteracting gas pressure and even more important, the inertial force from acceleration of the piston and conrod. Since the opposite inertial force occurs 180 degrees later in rotation, at that point this pressure is actually working AGAINST helping support the conrod from touching the crank. But fortunately the pressure is insignificant relative to the important fact, the continued existence of the oil film.
|
aughtsix
Expert Class
Posts: 277
|
posted August 26, 2005 05:34 PM
quote:
quote: I have to disagree, Slug.
The pressure from the oil pump is absolutely insignificant in compared to the pressures generated by combustion. The "push" that pressure is exerting in the opposite direction is relatively almost nothing.
Rather, what maintains the oil film despite being continually out the sides of the bearings, is FLOW.
Yes, you don't get flow without pressure, but the point is that it's not the pressure being applied to the oil film that matters, it's the existence of the oil film.
A thicker oil will take longer to be lost (leak out) from a bearing after loss of flow than will a thinner oil.
Right on... and sticky adds in the oil prevent it from rinsing off so quickly.
Tests have shown that many motors can run HOURS with no oil presssure as long as
they had some of these additives in the oil prior to draining it..
So Jere, going back in time to the 'hot toothpaste' thing, dare I ask what you use to make your oil 'sticky' ??
|
|
|
|
|