HOME ARTICLES JOIN GALLERY STORE SPONSORS MARKETPLACE CONTACT US  
Register | FAQ | Search | Memberlist
Username:    Password:       Forgot your password?
BIKELAND > FORUMS > ZX12R ZONE.com > Thread: SpencerCycle Product Release--This will help you guys ALOT NEW TOPIC NEW POLL POST REPLY
canadamaxxer


Pro
Posts: 1090
posted August 08, 2004 03:46 PM        
I assume that a Titanium bung is a little more tricky to locate?
  Ignore this member   
spencercyclecom


Zone Head
Posts: 535
posted August 08, 2004 10:44 PM        
dont have ti bungs
____________
Thanks
Doug Ray
SpencerCycle.com
SpencerCycle Center Inc.
Spencer Performance Group Inc.
Toll Free 1-800-510-1945 ext #10
International 1-800-510-1945 ext #11
Local/Tech 1-704-642-0987 ext #12
Fax 1-704-642-0987

  Ignore this member   
Zaphod Breeblebox


Expert Class
Posts: 117
posted August 09, 2004 11:17 AM        
One reason I'm interested in closed-loop FI systems for motorcycles is because of the ease of integrating aftermarket components.

For example, in the previously mentioned 1989 Mustang GT 5.0, you can do some quite extensive bolt-on modifications (aftermarket intake manifolds, heads, throttle bodies, mass air sensors, equal-length shorty headers, high-flow catalytic converters.....) and because the FI is closed-loop, no remapping of the ECM is necessary. The system will read the output of the oxygen sensors and keep the A/F ratio where it needs to be. Only when you get into very radical engine build situations does an aftermarket chip become necessary.

Contrast this to modern-day motorcycles. Here we are, 15 years after that old Mustang was manufactured, and something as simple as a slip-on exhaust requires a $300 Power Commander and a $150 dyno tuning session. Oops, just bought a high-flow air filter - there's another tuning session!

It just seems ridiculous to me that this should be necessary. The price of a closed-loop FI system from the factory would not increase the price of a new bike significantly, and would save lots of money downstream.

OK, I'm finished ranting.
____________
Zaphod
Y2K ZX-12R

  Ignore this member   
trenace


Needs a job
Posts: 3056
posted August 09, 2004 01:16 PM        Edited By: trenace on 9 Aug 2004 14:27
1) Car engines don't increase rpm as rapidly as supersport motorcycle engines do. The fact that the sensor is reporting what the engine *was* doing a short time back isn't as important with the car.

2) Nonetheless car engines often revert to open-loop under wide-open throttle.

3) The Mustang wasn't able to maintain a really correct air-fuel ratio in the first place, except as defined from the perspective of the catalytic converter or stoichiometric chemistry. In other words it tried to maintain 14.7 to 1, which is not the right ratio at all for power.

4) Mass air sensors are the real reason the cars were able to accomodate these changes: not closed-loop operation.

5) I disagree that the cost would not be significant -- it ought to add at least a couple of hundred bucks to the list price. (You don't stay in business by increasing the list by only as much as what you yourself had to pay to buy the components for as your general practice.)

6) As Doug said, even with this baby he's offering, let alone anything that was available at anything like the price point previously, open-loop is still the way to go for most actual operation!

So I don't agree that closed loop is a be-all, end-all answer for sport bikes, or even, all by itself a workable system.

For tourers, maybe.

It would make sense that it ought to appear on touring bikes first and then maybe, if and when the speed gets to where the system truly does know what the engine was doing only a couple of turns of the crank previously, closed-loop combined with some intelligent open-loop "adjustments" where it's known that conditions are changing especially rapidly. As my guess of things.

Another route could be an open-loop system that used sensor data to observe where, in actual operation, the air-fuel ratio was not appropriate, and with some intelligent algorithm, would with time and in an ongoing process remap the open-loop system according to a library of past data. So, not closed-loop in the immediate sense, but using the data to itself, over time, adjust its open-loop maps.

Or, another approach that could perhaps work would be a system that might kick in in the upper gears provided the clutch is fully out, there's no rapid change in the throttle or abnormally rapid change in rpm, etc. That could possibly be done right now for sportsbikes I'd guess, at least for 5th and 6th gear.

  Ignore this member   
Zaphod Breeblebox


Expert Class
Posts: 117
posted August 09, 2004 01:49 PM        
Thanks for the comments, trenace. I do disagree with a couple of things. Ok, three.

First, your comment that the mass air sensor is what made the car capable of accommodating those modifications is just simply not true. The mass air sensor is simply a sensor - another input to the ECM. It outputs a voltage depending on the quantity of air passing through it.

Second, you state that the stoichiometric A/F ratio is not appropriate "for all power." Is that true - what do you base that statement on?

Third, your comment about the cost of a closed-loop system. If it did add $200 to the cost of a new bike, that would still be cheaper than the cost of a Power Commander, which you will need at the drop of a hat. (Hell, some people say that you need a Power Commander to get stock bikes running right!) Figure a PC and the cost of a dyno tuning session would be about $450, and that's the breakeven point from the perspective of a single bolt-on mod to a bike.


____________
Zaphod
Y2K ZX-12R

  Ignore this member   
trenace


Needs a job
Posts: 3056
posted August 09, 2004 02:05 PM        Edited By: trenace on 9 Aug 2004 17:12
1) If you want to believe I believed or was trying to communicate that a mass air sensor in and of itself, just lying around somewhere, accomplished this feat then you may believe this. It's understandable you'd disagree with that.

What I was actually communicating was that the ECU is able to maintain an appropriate air/fuel ratio after changes such as you mentioned due to the mass air sensor detecting the resulting changes in air flow: NOT due to oxygen sensor and closed-loop operation correcting mixture as you stated.

2) I base it on about 25 years of various information and experiences along the way that 14.7 to 1 is not where you want to be for power. More like 12.5 to 1 for naturally aspirated, no more than about 13 to 1 anyway; more like 10.5 to 1 for turbo. But if you believe that 14.7 to 1 is the best ratio for power, OK.

By the way, what I'm saying is not an unusual opinion: so far as I know it's about universal, the only differences you will see -- for general opinions or for observed results with individual engines -- is in tenths of a point or half a point I believe. Even for cars.

Definitely please don't map your ZX-12R to 14.7 to 1.

3) We don't disagree on this point, except that you may not consider an increase of $200 to the list price to be significant, whereas my guess is manufacturers do consider it significant unless the feature is going to increase demand. If they could play it up successfully, have people hyped up that if they buy Brand A then they can do all these mods no sweat whereas with Brand B they can't, then maybe it could be that increased demand from the feature would outweigh the effect of higher price in decreasing demand.

If it worked.

But my other 5 points were that I don't think it would work. I would never deny that you can or should believe differently, I have only presented what I think, and why.

  Ignore this member   
Zaphod Breeblebox


Expert Class
Posts: 117
posted August 09, 2004 02:17 PM        Edited By: Zaphod Breeblebox on 9 Aug 2004 15:19
I appreciate your comments, trenace.

Particularly with regard to A/F ratio, that's an area I don't know much about. As you say, I've also read that different ratios can be appropriate for different applications - I don't really understand why, though. At any rate, an ECM in a closed-loop system can be programmed to return a variable ratio, not just stoichiometric. So that's not really an issue.

Back to the mass air sensor. I see where you're coming from, in that the engine as an air pump will have the capacity to pump a certain quantity of air depending on what you might do to the intake tract, exhaust, etc. And the quantity of air moving through the mass air sensor is a reflection of that. But it's only one piece of the puzzle. The true indication of how the engine is performing is measured at the output of the engine. In a closed-loop system, the return loop *is* the A/F ratio as measured at the oxygen sensor.
____________
Zaphod
Y2K ZX-12R

  Ignore this member   
Zaphod Breeblebox


Expert Class
Posts: 117
posted August 09, 2004 02:18 PM        
Oh, and don't worry about *me* mapping my ZX-12R - I'll leave that to someone that knows what the heck they're doing!
____________
Zaphod
Y2K ZX-12R

  Ignore this member   
canadamaxxer


Pro
Posts: 1090
posted August 09, 2004 02:40 PM        
Closed loop operation is primarily intended for emissions, not power. Closed loop systems still have to run in open loop during warm up (thus the need for heated O2 sensors....gets the vehicle into closed loop faster.....for better emissions sooner after the start of the warmup cycle) and in most cases at WOT. It is only due to processor speeds and the ability to interpolate data that the modern automotive systems can stay in closed loop as often as they do.....and the only reason why they did it was because the EMISSION standards have been made law. OBD I and II (on board diagnostics) only came around because the government made it law. Car manufacturers would probably prefered to use the carburetor until the cows came home if the government wouldn't have stepped in.

14.7 to 1 is consider the stoichiometric ratio: the ratio at which "perfect" combustion occurs. In this perfect world perfect combustion creates carbon dioxide and water.....but our world isn't perfect. 14.7 to 1 is a compromise in fuel economy, power and emissions. Higher than 14.7 to 1 causes an increase in fuel economy, but a loss of power and lots of times an increase in NOx emissions. Lower than 14.7:1 gives an increase in power, an increase in Carbon Monoxide emissions and a decrease in fuel economy. the books I have in front of me state that typically (generically) best power is at 12.5-12.7 to 1.

There are three main ways to calculate air flow entering an engine: speed density, Mass airflow, and Air vane. Air vane works by having the intake charge pressing against a hinged flapper door to which a potentiometer is attached. Mass airflow uses a sensor to calculate the temperature and density of the airflow to output a density value (seen in a frequency signal). Speed density uses a MAP sensor, IAT sensor and the TPS to calculate the air density inside the ECU. The ZX12 FI system is speed density. Speed density is not inferior to MAF, in fact I have heard of many Mustang drag racers retrofitting to speed density because the MAF system does not like the air flow speed changes as a result of having a lumpy cam.

From the research that I've done, few of the aftermarket FI system only have closed loop available even as an option....most don't even care to offer it. This means to me that in a pure performance envirnment where cost doesn't seem to be an object, the open loop system is still considered to be a better, simpler option. The O2 sensor readings, especially with a wide band readout like the one in this thread are a great tuning tool, but to improve the mapping we already have.

  Ignore this member   
Zaphod Breeblebox


Expert Class
Posts: 117
posted August 09, 2004 02:46 PM        
Thanks. Good info!
____________
Zaphod
Y2K ZX-12R

  Ignore this member   
fish_antlers


Administrator
The Truth is Out There
Posts: 21896
posted August 09, 2004 03:20 PM        
spencer... off topic check your PM's ...
____________
What business is it of yours where I'm from, Friendo?


  Ignore this member    Click here to visit fish_antlers's homepage. 
trenace


Needs a job
Posts: 3056
posted August 09, 2004 04:19 PM        Edited By: trenace on 9 Aug 2004 18:13
quote:
I appreciate your comments, trenace.

Hopefully they were of some value, there are others here that surely know more than I!

quote:
Particularly with regard to A/F ratio, that's an area I don't know much about. As you say, I've also read that different ratios can be appropriate for different applications - I don't really understand why, though. At any rate, an ECM in a closed-loop system can be programmed to return a variable ratio, not just stoichiometric. So that's not really an issue.

It is with the Mustang you cited, as it used a lambda-type sensor that isn't able to accurately measure air-fuel ratios much different than 14.7 to 1, and so the ECU can't accurately maintain any ratio very greatly different from that.

The newer wide-band sensors however are accurate over a wide range of air-fuel ratios, including those giving best power.

quote:
In a closed-loop system, the return loop *is* the A/F ratio as measured at the oxygen sensor.

However, it's a delayed result, and without the mass air sensor giving the immediate info on how much air is coming in and therefore how much fuel is needed, the lambda sensor alone would not have been sufficient input for the Mustang to have the engine running decently under all conditions. That was what I was saying, when the engine is accelerating or conditions are otherwise changing rapidly, feedback from the oxygen sensor only lets the engine know it was right or wrong a fraction of a second ago, not necessarily what it needs to do now to have correct mixture. This is why even the most advanced automotive systems today still go to open-loop under some circumstances often including full throttle, and then rely solely on other inputs to determine, along with the map, how much fuel is needed.

  Ignore this member   
spencercyclecom


Zone Head
Posts: 535
posted August 09, 2004 09:20 PM        
got cha.....Oliver. Expect it to be sent out in the am.

Doug
____________
Thanks
Doug Ray
SpencerCycle.com
SpencerCycle Center Inc.
Spencer Performance Group Inc.
Toll Free 1-800-510-1945 ext #10
International 1-800-510-1945 ext #11
Local/Tech 1-704-642-0987 ext #12
Fax 1-704-642-0987

  Ignore this member   
entropy


Moderator
Posts: 8671
posted August 10, 2004 01:52 AM        
Woo-hoo!

Doug gave me the full run-down yesterday; my LM-1 and rpm module should arrive on Thurs!!!!!

If I get rpm & tps hooked up, it oughta help me dial in my lockup
____________
This moderator uses moderation in moderation

  Ignore this member   
All times are America/Va [ This thread is 2 pages long: 1  2   ] < Previous Thread     Next Thread >
BIKELAND > FORUMS > ZX12R ZONE.com > Thread: SpencerCycle Product Release--This will help you guys ALOT NEW TOPIC NEW POLL POST REPLY

FEATURED NEWS   Bikeland News RSS Feed

HEADLINES   Bikeland News RSS Feed


Copyright 2000-2026 Bikeland Media
Please refer to our terms of service for further information
0.24965810775757 seconds processing time