Dino

Pro
Posts: 1422
|
posted September 22, 2004 07:49 PM
I was all for McCain 'till he let his views on gun control be known.
____________
uh oh
|
addisonzx12
Expert Class
Posts: 213
|
posted September 22, 2004 09:07 PM
I don't understand how the current administration gets so much support? Just what has it done RIGHT for the last 4 years? I can't think of anything! Anyway, I wish we could hold politicians to their election promises. For instance, if Bush was to promise that there would be no draft, unless some COUNTRY declared war on us! Now if he changed his mind, we should be able to impeach him! Because, if he was to declare his intent to reinstate the draft after the election, does anyone think he would have a chance in hell of getting re-elected? I think not!!
|
Otis

Needs a job
Captain Kickstand
Posts: 3028
|
posted September 23, 2004 04:18 AM
Vincent, I read through your post and can't see the answer to my questions. I see you lashing out at Republicans but not a clear answer to your thoughts on the current Democratic Party and it's operatives, and I don't mean just Al Gore. I truly want to know what you think about the Dem's and their agenda now, compared to then. Please, I know you have strong thoughts about this, you must, and I say that because I see you as a old school Democrat, not one of the new one's. I watched Zell's speech at the Republican convention, and while I was scepticle for sure about his intentions and he was a bit over the top in his approach, one thing I didn't see in him was disengenuousness. He truly is mad at his party and where it has gone. I see you more like him than just a blind follower of the party. I wrote this on another board about Zell's speech to show why I thought it was a key moment for anyone paying attention to what is really going on around here.
************************************************************I thought Rudy was good, I thought McCain was good, I thought Arnold was good, I thought the Bush girls were ditzes and embarrassing, I thought Cheney was good too. But the only reason I am even posting this thread is to comment on Zell Miller's speech. It was powerful, just blew me away. So much so that I got on the phone to call my dad and his phone was busy, he was trying to call me at the same time. We just flat couldn't believe how powerful Zell's words were. And not the blasts against Kerry and the Democratic party, they were not what got me. It was Zells understanding of this time in history and what it means for his family, for MY family. When he spoke of his grandkids I thought about my 2 little girls sleeping in their bedrooms and it hit home what this election really means. He is a lifelong Democrat who recognizes that at this moment of time in our country we need a certain kind of leader and what political party that leader comes from is irrelevent, but what that leader is made of is CRITICAL. While I was voting for GW anyway this speech by Zell made me realize the importance of this vote and that GW wins. How anyone can overlook the powerful statements by this man is beyond me.
God Bess this country and this President
Let me know your thoughts Vin, without speaking about Rebublican's please.
|
slug

Pro
Out in search of my mind...
Posts: 1433
|
posted September 23, 2004 04:59 AM
Otis: zell is one of a kind, they don't make politicans like him any more. i wish they did, we wouldn't be where we are now.
he's one of the honest ones, he knows what is at stake, and his party allegiance is second to his family and the security of his constituents. Max Cleland let his party allegience override the security of his constituents, and they fired him. It's a shame that so many people ignore dangerous thingslike that and blindly follow the party allegience.
for example: one of the electricians working on the job site is die-hard union. so he votes democrat, regardless of who it is or what they stand for. Once you get beyond party afiliation, he's a hard worker, probablymakes a buttload more than i do, he enjoys outdoors, hunting fishing etc, beleives in freedom and liberty and the constitution. but he votes for a party because (i may be wronghere on this) they are supported by his union, even though that party supports some opposite views right now. that's the only coherent reason i could get from him on it at all, because the democrats support labor unions, they *must* be the working man's friends.
he spouted the same 'tax cuts for the rich' nonsense that percolates everywhere. he played the same class warfare card that we get on this same forum.
how hard is it to get: when the tax RATES go down, people keep MORE of their money. the chunk of change kept is HIGHER For those with higher income, because the rates are a PERCENTAGE. the money did NOT come from the poor people, because the money those rates affected HAD NOT YET BEEN COLLECTED. the "great tax giveaway to the rich" is a huge LIE that is perpetuated by anyone who spouts that same sorry and tired 'tax breaks for the rich, government corporate welfare etc" lines. IT DOESN'T EXIST because the rates affect INCOME to the government. INCOME means money coming IN, not going out. but with the governmente education system we have, people won't understand that.
i bet Otis understands it clearly though, being one of those 'evil filthy rich' ; and as small business owner (which most of the 'evil filthy rich' are....) HE and millions of "evil rich" americans like him is responsible for the largest chunk of economy improvement and jobs creation. Does anyone here think small businesses steal from the poor and give to the rich? Then why do they say the VERY thing by implication about rich people? (BTW if you make over 50k/year, you are in the "rich" group of americans....)
these discussions are tiresome because people find it easier to attribute a person's income to nefarious acts than hard work. Yes, there are a small number of hte "socially elite" (i like that little term of endearment too) that don't work very "hard" to be rich, like marrying in to money, or winninglottery, or getting inheritance....but then again those sorts of things are prety rare. VERY publicised, but very rare. Most millionaires are self-made, they worked their butts off, took high risks, etc, and reap the benefits.
yet they are all condemned by the democratic party (who almost entirely consist of rich people, well the ones in positions of control in the party anyway....) interesting.
Doi like either party? no. they both will get us to the same socialized welfare state eventually. one or the other may take longer, but they are both headed that way. every election year, they cross sides more and more in attempts to win those fence-sitting voters, or to win the pragmatic party voters. looking at the kerry and bush platforms, they essentially read the same. the only difference is the man behind the platform, and the biggest difference is the attitude of both towards the single greatest security threat to the USA. one has no questiona bout the course of action, and is pursuing it 100%. the other has waffled so many times on that ONE topic it is sad, yet amusing, yet scary. scary that he may have had the chance of winning in november.
but i will AGAIN make this disclaimer, because it seems that no matter how many time s i state it, *SOMEONE* will just dismiss the views above as the 'rants' of a 'bush man' or what not. I support bush because he is the only one of the 4 candidates this year that i feel will CONTINUE to be strong military leader and STRONG threat to terror.
i honestly believe that kerry elected to office WILL result in higher level of terrorist action against our troops. and WILL result in a larger number of the kidnapping & beheading cycle. Why? Not because "daddy cheney" as some one so eloquently put it said so. but because Kerry's position is liquid, and the past record of kerry shows a disdain for anything military. it also shows that he has stated openly that he thinks we should not be in iraq, or that we should but differently, or that we should never have gone but removed saddam hussein somehow, or that we should have gone but should not be there now, or or or or... How could the terrorists NOT want to do something drastic to attempt to test the mettle of a person who cannot even have the balls to say one thing consistantly over a stupid ELECTION campaign? can we afford that in the oval office in charge of our friends HDL and kawachan and beans and all the rest?
do you HONESTLY trust that John Kerry is the man to lead those people? Canyou honestly say that John Kerry will steadfastly ignore the NYT and hollywood polls saying that the war is evil and wrong, and continue to support the troops, and not waver when the going gets tough? Canyou honestly say that you know for a FACT what John Kerry stnads for, when discussing hte war in iraq? Because *I* can not. i have seen as many as 4 DIFFERENT points of view from john kerry in the last year on this ONE topic. FOUR different stands. FOUR different ways he claims he would do it. From 100% like Bush did it (last december) to 100% NOT going at all (within the last week "if you were elected president in 2000, would we bein iraq?" "no not at all" )
which is it? do you trust John Kerry with HDL's life? If you do, WHAT makes you think John Kerry is the right man to be in charge of them?
GW Bush may not be a good speaker, he may have signed huge spending bills, and pushed for creation of the ministry of homeland defense, and many other things. But his stance with the military has been single-minded, no questions, no backing down. And it keeps them safer, because the enemy has no real thoughts that we can be bcked down. Our troops have 100% support from their commander in chief. their CIC has NEVER wavered when it has come to terrorist attacks on troops or civilians. He won't back down, and they know it. Our troops know that we won't back down as well, and THAT can only bolster morale.
I know what it is like to serve under a commander inchief who may or may not support the military when it came to military action. creates a certain stress ya know?
the very thought of John Kerry's wishy-washy attitude and elitism makes me concerned for the friends and family i ahve over in iraq all the more.
will terrorist attacks continue in iraq and the world? yes. until we root out the little bastards and lock them away or send them to their maker. but it is infinitely better to fight them over there, than here in middle of tennesee, or new york city again, or LA. The language of John Kerry implies that he would rather wait to act until they attack here. IMHO that's too late.
|
VincentHill

Needs a life
Posts: 6520
|
posted September 23, 2004 05:00 AM
Otis, I heard very little of Zell Miller's speach. When he started out yelling, I turned the Channel. I am even changing the church (not religion) because my church has gotten too loud. I really believe that Kerry will make a better president than Bush II ever could. (Bush has a good team but it is Bush himself I object to) If you only have 1 thought and 1 idea, then it is very easy to keep on target. The Only time he is by himself and tells the truth (When he said that we may not win the war in Iraq then everybody jumps all over him, then how can he be his own man?)
The Clinton style Democrat is the New Democrat. One that realized that Big Government cannot do all and Be All is what I think is possible. I think that Kerry will be in that style. Remember one other thing that you have not taken into consideration. I live on the Plantation in DC. We pay taxes and get no vote on anything. I watch the Republicans veto everything to do with Home Rule. Clinton had on the DC tags (All tags have this) Taxation without Representation. Bush Had these tags removed. How do you think this makes people that have no vote feel? SO as you can see it is a lot of things that Bush himself either did or did not do that makes me think he is not the Man for the Job. If I lived elsewhere, then I could feel a little different, but I live here and have "No Senators, No Representatives and DC has more people than several other states! That is not Fair and it is not AMERICAN!
____________
Made History @ Daytona and still one fast old man!!
|
Otis

Needs a job
Captain Kickstand
Posts: 3028
|
posted September 23, 2004 05:50 AM
Vincent, I was really hoping for more from you on this. You are obviously not interested in answering my question thoughtfully, and that's OK, it's a free country.
Thinking that John Kerry will be like Clinton actually made me laugh out loud. I wonder though Vincent, as you obviously care very much about kawachan, a good friend of yours. Did you read Slug's post? A post from another Vet and obviously a man who is very smart and understands the military, are you calling him wrong in his thoughts about Kerry and what he would mean to the men in the service? If kawachan, during one of your conversations with him, told you that he would rather have GW as the next President because of his unwavering support for the military, would you tell him he doesn't know what he is talking about, Kerry is better?
Slug, very well said, as usual.
|
addisonzx12
Expert Class
Posts: 213
|
posted September 23, 2004 06:42 AM
Terrorists, terrorism!! The only positive thing anybody can seem to say about the Bush administration is he's better at fighting the terrorists. What terrorists? Where? We are chasing ghosts! Just how many terrorists are there in the world? 1,000, 10,000, 100,000, 1,000,000? Just who the hell are we fighting? Terrorism is like prostitution, it has always been here & will always be! When somebody gets mugged in a park, what is it? Terrorism, right? Think about it. If the Hells Angels, who probably have more members than Bin Ladens group declared War on the United States, would the whole country just come to a stop? Now don't get me wrong. Terrorism is something that I wish did not exist, it is a terrible thing. But basing the whole election on that solely, is just foolish. You can't let fear of a very small group of people, make your decisions for you! That is exactly what they want!!
|
jonwright

Needs a job
Posts: 2416
|
posted September 23, 2004 07:37 AM
quote: but with the governmente education system we have, people won't understand that.
Posted by Slug.
Evidently you went to the public govermente schools?
Good point, Addison.
*sigh* I wish McCain were running. It's just gotta stab him in the heart to stand there and stump for Bush. Remember when he said those stupid ads about Kerry's Vietnam record that the Bush admin supposedly had nothing to do with?
McCain said they were a disgrace - after that they had him stumping for Bush. Seems like he got beat down pretty hard for that. Ouch.
|
slug

Pro
Out in search of my mind...
Posts: 1433
|
posted September 23, 2004 08:06 AM
gubmerment skools didnt teech me to tipe ;P
many of hte ads on both sides are a disgrace
but in the US media, only one set of ads are a disgrce, the swift boat vet ads,a nd the bush ads. the others are the gospel truth...
Addison: you're right in a way, basing our decisions on their actions *can* be considered a win for them. except that the decision made is to get rid of them to the best of our military's ability.
Spain's election, which was totally changed by terrorist acts, is a showcase of the *wrong* choice made that HELPS the terrorist cause. going after them doesn't let them win. in thelong runthey will lose, and lose all.
It would be a win to let one of their acts cause the USA or any other country to stop fighting the evil they represent. Fighting against the murder of innocents is NEVER bad business. If someone thinks it is bad business, then i really don't think i want to associate with that person.
Iraq is going to set the tone of the next 10-20 years. If the middle east has a self-governed, popularly elected government based on freedom and liberty of the citizens, i think the entire area will have some SERIOUS reorganization, and we will all be the better for it. Even the people who are fighting it tooth and nail. and RPG and AK47....
If we cut and run, or pull out prematurely, there is no doubt in my mind that the efforts of ALL who have been there, who have bled there, who have died there, will be a complete and utter waste. The ones who are perpetrating the terrorist acts will take over, and iraq will return to the same future it had before hussein was removed: bleak and violent.
we cannotlet one issue decide the election, that is true. but we must accept that the reality of the world can have a SERIOUS AND DEADLY impact on every other facet of our lives. A few plane crashes left our nation stopped dead for several days. It placed a large instantaneous drop in our economy.
another attack of that or greater magnitude will uproot every gain that has been made since then. everything goes back to stability and security. If we are safe & stable, everything goes 1000 times better. When things are insecure, or unstable, most people are edgy and not willing to take risks. companies do the 'safe' thing, and growth slows or stops.
domestic and foreign are interconnected. both rely on the other to run well. if we allow foreign interests to wreak havoc on foreign economies, we will feel it here.
like i said before, both platforms are essentially the same. they say the same things. the way the goals will bemet are a bit different, but otherwise, they are both 'for' the same things (as far as mainstream issues go)
so no real change there. the only major difference is the appearance of resolve. and that is what i base my choices on. If lieberman or mcain were there, i'd vote for them. but they aren't so i have to make the choice that i feel is best for my friends and family who are overseas fighting for freedom and liberty. Who are keeping the terrorists busy over there, so they are too busy to act out over here in my home town, or in yours. My decision is notbased solely on terrorism, but terrorism is the only major difference....so maybe you're right, i am foolish
i'd rather be foolish and see my friends and family again, and not have to replace 9/11 in the tragedies file with a newer date...
|
ridgeracer

Pro
Posts: 1309
|
posted September 23, 2004 08:28 AM
Otis I'm confused. You say your patriotism is almost religious in its zeal and that when in doubt you take it on faith that America is good and will always do the right thing. You are a Nationalist. Then you say you want to have a discussion based on truth and reasoning. Which is it? How can we reason with someone who filters everything through their faith in government?
This is the answer to the question so many people have as to why can't some republicans see what a failure Bush is. They are Human.
I knew a guy in high school. Jock, best car in school, ladies man, rich parents. When he was 22, driving the same car, he went speeding down an ally, drunk, in the middle of the day ran over and killed two little toddlers on big wheels, killed them both. He is in prison. Talk to mom and she will tell you how awful it was that the parents let those kids play in the ally. She cant face the fact that her son is responsible for killing two little kids. Why? Is it because she blames herself for raising a spoiled kid who still lived at home at 22 and drank during the day and she didn't do anything about it? So much easier for her to blame an another, to live in denial.
I had this conversation when I was teaching high school in the late '90s
Me: Your son brought a gun to school.
Parents: You had not right to search is locker
But your son brought a GUN to school!
What right did you have to search his locker!
I understand why so many hate Kerry becasue he spoke against the war. In Vietnam many many men watched some of their closest friends die agonizing brutal deaths. They also where ordered or forced into situations that made them do unspeakable things to other human beings. Now when you come out of that hell you have to believe it was for a reason, that you served some greater good. Otherwise your friend got blown up and you lost your leg for nothing. As a parent who wants to live with the knowledge that they encouraged their child to go to war and told them they were proud of them and then they were killed for no good reason. People lie to themselves all the time to preserve their worldview. Everyone wants to be the good guys.
Now I don't want to get into a big argument about whether the Vietnam war was or was not just, right, etc. It doesn't matter one way or the other to make my point. In fact it works both ways. Some people come out of it looking for someone to blame for what they did. They are also blinded to the truth.
Otis, of course you believe Bush is an intelligent and capable leader and is doing the right thing for America. And of course we are totally blameless for 911. And of course Iraq is a just and legal war, we had to, absoulutly had to go in there when we did to save america and your two little girls. My god, if thats not the truth then that would mean.......oh, no..........I can't believe that.....
They don't say ignorance is bliss for nothing! Believe me I would rather live in a Tom Clancy Novel. But my intellect, not my faith tells me different.
Its like the Matrix, do you want the red pill or the blue pill Otis.
BTW did any of you notice the political message of the Matrix? You have the Agent Smiths, the 'suits' obviously representing the establishment, all the really powerful bad guys are white men, doing battle with those who have had their eyes opened, the very ethnic, running around in rags, third worldish, people of Zion. They do battle in the Matrix were most people have no idea their life is a lie.
Its like religion vs science, Creationism vs Evolution. One is dogma, the other based on reasoning. I don't claim to know the 'absolute truth' of anything. But I have a pretty good working model. It is not set in stone, it adapts to new evidence. And it explains most things without having to do any mental contortions.
Take 9/11. All these people running around...."Why would anyone do this to us, were the GOOD guys, why do they hate us!?" And what was the intellectual in depth reasoned explination? They hate our Freedom. They hate us BECAUSE we are good. We are just SO good they can't stand it....cause they are so bad. Yes thats it...how stupid of us not to see it.
Of course people like me were not suprised. In fact a friend and I were discussing this very subject over a beer the night before. He was the first person to call me on 9/11 and ask if I had seen what happened and said "Can you believe we were just talking about this last night?" Our discussion was not IF there would be a terrorist attack rather it was if it would be foriegn or domestic. Jihadists or another McVeigh.
Now about the mental contortions I spoke about. It seems in your belief system, your world model, that any one who is critical of the Good Guys must be crazy. We cheer when america is attacked, we like it when the economy goes south. Do you really believe that? That we pray for things to go wrong? The fact you mentioned the term 'operatives ' and Al Franken tells me you listen to the right wing noise machine like Rush or O'Reilly or Fox News.
I listen to Rush (keep your friends close, keep your enemies closer) and I can tell you he is full of shit because he is not the ONLY thing I listen too. I'll give you a prime example Rush says this all the time. When talking about Bush just sitting in the classroom for seven minutes on 9/11 he will then say well nobody realized it was a terrorist attack until the SECOND plane hit the WTC, which is true. He doesn't really say it but the obvious conclusion any normal person would draw was that Bush sat there because he had been told only the FIRST plane had hit.
The TRUTH (its on video) is the frist plane hit before bush got to the school. He was asked about it by a reporter going into the school and quiped, that must be one bad pilot, and just sat there for seven minutes after being told the second plane had hit. Rush is a master at inuendo. If you called him on this one he could say I never said he was told it was the first plane in the class. Which would be true. But if you polled everyone who only listens to rush you know what they would say.
Now to answer your questions about democrats, and make Rush like a bigger idiot. Yes the Democratic party is no longer the Party of FDR. After 12 years of Reagan Bush the DLC (Democratic Leadership Council) persuaded the party to move to the right. They called it centrist but they became Republican Lite. I'm a liberal. Clinton IS NOT a liberal.
Would a liberal sign NAFTA or GATT?
Burlington Northern rail workers go on strike. Would a liberal declare the railroad a national security infastructure and outlaw the strike?
He kicked thousands of people off welfare.
What did he do to fight the Death Penalty?
Did he raise the CAFE standards or do anything to really protect the enviornment?
He protected some land just before he left office so he would have a legacy for the history books but him and gore were both frauds when it came to the enviornment.
Nixon did more for the enviornment then they did. He had nothing like LBJs Great Society or FDRs New Deal.
But to listen to the right you would think he was Carl Marx. And there is a reason for this. It limits debate. If Clinton is the ultra liberal then how can anyone possibly be to the left of Clinton?
As for Zell Miller, What would you say if told you every single weapons system he said Kerry 'tried to kill' were also listed by Dick Chenney when he was Sec Defense under Bush 41 as not needed anymore?
For example, it was Dick Cheney himself, in his capacity as Secretary of Defense under President George H.W. Bush, who testified before the House Armed Services Committee on 13 August 1989 that he had recommended cancelling the AH-64 Apache Helicopter program:
quote: The Army, as I indicated in my earlier testimony, recommended to me that we keep a robust Apache helicopter program going forward. AH-64 . . . forced the Army to make choices. I said, "You can't have all three. We don't have the money for all three." So I recommended that we cancel the AH-64 program two years out. That would save $1.6 billion in procurement and $200 million in spares over the next five years.
(Note that this testimony took place over six years before Senator Kerry supposedly voted to "kill" the AH-64.)
Likewise, on 1 February 1992, Secretary of Defense Cheney complained to the Senate Armed Services Committee that he was being "forced" to spend money on unneeded weapons such as the M-1, the F-14, and the F-16:
quote: Congress has let me cancel a few programs. But you've squabbled and sometimes bickered and horse-traded and ended up forcing me to spend money on weapons that don't fill a vital need in these times of tight budgets and new requirements . . . You've directed me to buy more M-1s, F-14s, and F-16s all great systems . . . but we have enough of them.
And President Bush noted in his 1992 State of the Union address that he was phasing out several weapons systems, including the B-2, to "reflect the changes of the new era":
quote: Two years ago, I began planning cuts in military spending that reflected the changes of the new era. But now, this year, with imperial communism gone, that process can be accelerated. Tonight I can tell you of dramatic changes in our strategic nuclear force. These are actions we are taking on our own because they are the right thing to do. After completing 20 planes for which we have begun procurement, we will shut down further production of the B-2 bombers. We will cancel the small ICBM program. We will cease production of new warheads for our sea-based ballistic missiles. We will stop all new production of the Peacekeeper missile. And we will not purchase any more advanced cruise missiles.
|
ridgeracer

Pro
Posts: 1309
|
posted September 23, 2004 10:03 AM
quote: It would be a win to let one of their acts cause the USA or any other country to stop fighting the evil they represent. Fighting against the murder of innocents is NEVER bad business. If someone thinks it is bad business, then i really don't think i want to associate with that person.
In this war, there are some terrorists the Bush administration favors. One is Orlando Bosch, the anti-communist Cuban exile who master-minded the bombing of a Cuban civilian airliner in 1976 that killed 73 passengers, among them the entire Cuban Olympic fencing team.
Bosch had been held in prison in Venezuela from 1976 until 1986 in connection with the bombing. Reich was U.S. Ambassador to Venezuela from 1986 to 1989. Soon after Reich arrived, Bosch's case was reopened and he was released. A close collaborator of the CIA, Bosch was eventually given asylum in the United States where former CIA head, then president, George Bush pardoned him for various other illegal acts in 1990.
I'm still kinda of fuzzy on this good / evil thing.....maybe you can help me out
Bosch? Good or Evil?
In the Central American nation of Nicaragua, a war was raging. An army of guerrillas was engaged in a struggle to overthrow the Communist regime which had recently come to power. The Reagan administration supported the revolutionary force, known as the Contras, in their bid to overthrow the Sandinistas and restore a pro-American government to Nicaragua.
Unfortunately, the Congress felt differently. Much differently. So differently, in fact, that it passed a set of laws making it a crime to give aid to the Contras. In doing so, the U.S. government had forbidden itself from furnishing the Contras with money or supplies of any kind.
The White House was suddenly facing a crisis. They weren't allowed to send money. But even if they were, where would they get it? During a June 1984 meeting of the National Security Planning Group, the President and his closest advisors weighed their options:
KIRKPATRICK: If we can't get the money for the anti-Sandinistas, then we have to make the maximum effort to find the money elsewhere.
SCHULTZ: I would like to get the money for the Contras also, but ... Jim Baker said that if we go out and try to get the money from third countries, it is an impeachable offense.
CASEY: Jim Baker said that if we try to get money from third countries without notifying the oversight committees it could be a problem.
SCHULTZ: Baker's argument is that the U.S. government may raise and spend funds only through an appropriation of the Congress.
PRESIDENT REAGAN: We must obtain the funds to help these freedom fighters.
VICE PRESIDENT BUSH: The only problem that might come up is if the United States were to promise to give these third parties something in return, so that some people could interpret this as some kind of an exchange.
McFARLANE: I certainly hope none of this discussion will be made public in any way.
PRESIDENT REAGAN: If such a story gets out, we'll all be hanging by our thumbs in front of the White House until we find out who did it.
But despite the efforts of the White House PR machine, the Contras increasingly appeared to be a particularly ruthless and bloodthirsty bunch. Stories of atrocities against civilian noncombatants certainly didn't help. In the words of human rights group Americas Watch, "the Contras systematically engage in violent abuses ... so prevalent that these may be said to be their principle means of waging war." Another NGO compiled a year's worth of Contra atrocities, which included murder, rape, torture, maiming children, cutting off arms, cutting out tongues, gouging out eyes, castration, bayoneting pregnant women in the stomach, and amputating genitals.
Contras: Good or Evil?
I could go on and on but I think I already know the answer....
US sponsered terrorism; Good
Everyone else; Evil
quote:
The nationalist not only does not disapprove of atrocitites committed by his own side, but he has a remarkable capacity for not even hearing about them.
George Orwell, "Notes on Nationalism" 1945
|
slug

Pro
Out in search of my mind...
Posts: 1433
|
posted September 23, 2004 10:13 AM
as usual you have completely failed to actually address the true questions Otis asked, and repeat the same thing you ahve said over and over again....
we get it, noone really cares for bush or his dometic spending
where is the failure, you say bush failed in alot of places, but you never ever ever ever ever ever ever have cited WHAT his failures are, just that he has them.
i too tire of rush, he is a republican mouthpiece, even managed to explain away and defend Bush's stupid amnesty for illegals push.
fox news or cnn or whatever, it all has to be balanced with other sources. i think fox has a conservative bias, because it is a conservative view that allows and attempts to coexist with other points of view. they do have many anchors who are very liberal, and for the most part, i have found their coverage to be mostly adequate. there are still many examples where the conservative bias shows through, but they get it right more times than not....NYT or SeeBS are quite the opposite....
Your comments about the 'why' of the terroist attacks, you say it ingenuously, but the reality is this: terrorists want the world to live under one islamic government that THEY approve of. they want to kill all non-muslims, and all muslims who don't think the way they do. We are a double target, because we are one of the biggest things standing in the way of a one-world islamic theocratic government, and we are a nation that is pretty much non-muslim.
the reasons that were cited for the attack onthe WTC were something to affect of 'bringing the USA and its economy to its knees' or some such. yet the attack was symbolic also due to the multiple nationalities represented inthe WORLD trade center. the strike was not at the USA, but at the entire non-muslim world.
but i guess i am too thick for that appraisal to be worth anything
let's see if we can answer Otis' questions...it doesn't seem like anyone is really willing to do so.
|
slug

Pro
Out in search of my mind...
Posts: 1433
|
posted September 23, 2004 10:18 AM
Edited By: slug on 23 Sep 2004 11:20
i'd be curious to see the actual sources of that convo you posted, it would lshed a lot of light on things
so you believe that saddam hussein should still be in power
that al queda is ok and should be left alone? those poor misunderstood people. awww, here let's sharpen their knives for them so they can behead a few more people.....
thanks for clarifying....i'm not voting for bush1 or reagan.......i'mnot voting for clinton, or for dukakis or for nixon or for carter or JFK
my choices are GW Bush and John Kerry.
let's stop with the smoke & mirrors and get to the real topic at hand...
canyou answer Otis' questions? or are you going to evade them some more?
edit: i hope you don't get the impression that i don't care about past things that were done that were wrong, but i want to know how those past actions define the present ones?
|
Otis

Needs a job
Captain Kickstand
Posts: 3028
|
posted September 23, 2004 10:39 AM
Edited By: Otis on 23 Sep 2004 11:44
Ridge you don't know me so I am confused on how you are so able to assume things about me. I was considering responding to your post with my thoughts on things when I began reading until I came upon this:
Otis, of course you believe Bush is an intelligent and capable leader and is doing the right thing for America. And of course we are totally blameless for 911. And of course Iraq is a just and legal war, we had to, absoulutly had to go in there when we did to save america and your two little girls. My god, if thats not the truth then that would mean.......oh, no..........I can't believe that.....
The second you wrote about my little girls in a sarcastic statement means I am done with you, forever.
|
ridgeracer

Pro
Posts: 1309
|
posted September 23, 2004 11:28 AM
My apologies for offending you. I was speaking generally but used you specifcally as the subject. That was wrong. I should of used people and children instead of Otis and your girls.
Again my apologies.
|
jonwright

Needs a job
Posts: 2416
|
posted September 23, 2004 11:42 AM
Edited By: jonwright on 23 Sep 2004 12:43
quote: where is the failure, you say bush failed in alot of places, but you never ever ever ever ever ever ever have cited WHAT his failures are, just that he has them.
How 'bout these? I posted 'em already.
quote: 1. Campaigns on small gov't.
Reality - personal invasions (which I see as BIG gov't) such as Patriot Act and the current initiative to combat terrorism that are not used for such (what FBI agent really thinks looking at the BOOKS a person reads makes them a terrorist?) Another example: Cat Stephens. What's up with that?
2. Campaigns on being fiscally responsible
Reality - Budget deficit, anyone? Yeah - I got a problem with that.
3. Campaigns on changing the 'tone in Washington'
Reality - did 'push polling' in the primaries spreading untrue rumors about McCain. Dirty politics at it's worst. Also said that Clinton Administration trashed white house on transition, a report the GOA later ruled to be false. Cheney says that if Kerry is elected Al-Quaida will strike again (how about fear mongering and wishing ill on someone?)
4. Powell: "We know where the WMD's are"
Reality - Rumsfeld: "Well, it's a big desert, ya know."
How 'bout this:
Bush says economy is doing well.
Net jobs lost outpace jobs created. Also given that most of job created would appear to be low-paying service jobs that further explains why food stamp subscriptions (for lack of a better word) are UP something like 2.x%. Good economy?
How about the export of jobs?
The blue collar guys already suffered through that in the 90's. Now we are seeing the export of white collar jobs (one of my clients moved their programming ops overseas and laid off several hundred folks - they weren't offered a relo package to India, BTW).
Yeah - I'm concerned about that because if many jobs are now overseas - where the hell is my paycheck coming from? And I won't have health insurance etc. etc. This affects the fabric of our society - much more than some stupid bullshit about stem cell research (Bush is ignorant on that as well).
Hey, that Clinton Army kick some ass in Iraq or what?
|
jonwright

Needs a job
Posts: 2416
|
posted September 23, 2004 11:45 AM
...and don't get me started on Ashcroft. The fact that Bush appointed him to a cabinet position is very disconcerting. Hell, his home state wouldn't even elect him over a dead man.
|
jonwright

Needs a job
Posts: 2416
|
posted September 23, 2004 11:47 AM
PLUS he's to blame for the hurricanes
....because God is really mad since Bush stole the election in 2000.
Now Florida has to suffer because of it.
These hurricanes are hitting around election time, ya know........
|
jonwright

Needs a job
Posts: 2416
|
posted September 23, 2004 11:50 AM
quote: that al queda is ok and should be left alone? those poor misunderstood people. awww, here let's sharpen their knives for them so they can behead a few more people.....
Um, it's called empathy. See quotes re: Sun Tzu, McNamara, and Machiavelli above.
Just because you understand your enemy doesn't mean you excuse what they do.
|
deathpulse

Pro
Posts: 1688
|
posted September 23, 2004 01:17 PM
hmm.. I would argue that we DO know the enemy, although I guess this is an arguable possition. Sun Tzu is a very good source for battle advice, business advice (really close to battle) and sometimes relationship advice - but you must take heed to balance his various passages as well. The actual passage (from Chapter 3 of the translated text) reads:
Therefore, there are five factors of knowing who will win:
One who knows when he can fight, and when he cannot fight, will be victorious;
one who knows how to use both large and small forces will be victorious;
one who knows how to unite upper and lower ranks in purpose will be victorious;
one who is prepared and waits for the unprepared will be victorious;
one whose general is able and is not interfered by the ruler will be victorious.
These five factors are the way to know who will win.
Therefore I say:
One who knows the enemy and knows himself will not be in danger in a hundred battles.
One who does not know the enemy but knows himself will sometimes win, sometimes lose.
One who does not know the enemy and does not know himself will be in danger in every battle.
I would say (my own opinion) that I personally do not trust John Kerry's judgement on the first point of the 5 factors essential to determining who will win a war (One who knows when he can fight, and when he cannot fight, will be victorious) - especially since Kerry seems to want to farm this decision out to the UN or some other outside body... which brings me to the second concern that I have with Kerry from a Chapter 3 perspective which is "one whose general is able and is not interfered by the ruler will be victorious". This is a REAL issue from a "let the UN lead our decisions to go into battle" perspective. Bush I think has the right idea on this one - let the generals do the fighting and call the shots, just manage the overall decision. I think Kerry would have this decision "outsourced" to the UN or to some other international body - bad bad bad idea from a Sun Tzu perspective.
Now - please keep in mind, that this passage is only a portion of Sun Tzu's advice in chapter 3, otherwise known as the "planning attacks" section. There are 13 other chapters and they cover some interesting stuff. The real danger though is quoting only a small portion of the verses... which I may be accused of as well. You kinda need to read it in total, which I encourage everyone to do!
|
slug

Pro
Out in search of my mind...
Posts: 1433
|
posted September 23, 2004 03:04 PM
the problem with those "failures" is that the president, WHOMEVER they are, is not the one who can fix or not fix them (except cheney's comments about al queda, which, personally, as i stated above, i do happen to agree with. is that fear-mongering? or is that the realities of life? show weakness, and terrorists strike....see also: spain, russia, saudi arabia, etc)
the president signs the law making congress' budget valid. The president does NOT insert all the pork and crap that is wasted money. that got added in by the members of the congressional comittee that revised the budget....you can even check the comments made by the head of that comittee on that very subject.
should bush have signed the budget? in my opinion, no, but with reservations and understanding of why it was signed. there are several other reasons to sign it that i can see and maybe understand. first: if budget isn't signed you run in to government shutdowns, etc etc. we don't need that in time of war. You get in to the more obnoxious messes associated with trying to deprive congressional members of their pet monetary projects. etc etc. When we have a war going on, do we have the time to let them bicker back and forth?
not at all. but i would prefer that he had NOT signed the budgets as presented. REALLY need a line-item veto, so that the excess garbage canbe excised and we don't have the problem with good legislation being killed by stupid provisions.
Line-item veto would mostlikely solve MANY president's so-called "failures"
so budget. yeh, his responsibility, but not really his doing.
smaller government: i agree totally, the ministry of homeland defense is a waste of time & money. it created nothing except more layers of BS paperwork.
Please also cite actual and real examples of patriot act abuses. i'd love to add some to my list, but i have a very small list, because i can't find any viable and credible evidence to support it being abused. I dislike patriot act, because i think it CAN be misused. but haven't seen it done yet...
but is that the fault of the president when a law gets misused? in this case, apparently so. But when a different president and different administration were in power, it was ok for government agents to shoot children and burn out women & children in 'raids' for undersized shotgun barrels.... no-one seemed to give a s**t then. oh well, it's ok, the feds said they were child molesters, so kill the whole group! Is that clinton's fault? no. But it IS bush's fault if the homeland defense dept were to misuse its power, or even have the ABILITY to misuse power....
Cat Stevens: who knows, he showed up on a terrorist watch list for some reason, why did they even let him ON the plane in first place?
but it is Bush's fault that cat stevens or whatever he calls himself now got detained for a while...
see, i get the gist of the whole campaign. as long as you express a hatred of bush, life is ok, and we can justify everything we say by making everything bush was around evil and wrong.
the tone in washington was interestingly amiable last year. even up to december, democrats and republicans were side by side on iraq, side by side on MANY things that they are diametrically opposed on now.
but last december there was no presidential election.
this year there is....
the tone has been set though, for the last 6-9 months, the 'hate bush' mantra has been repeated and spouted and beaten to death.
but it is Bush's fault those people changed their minds this spring...
i guess i missed that memo....
it's funny, even Kerry agreed with and wholly supported bush's actions last year.... but this year there's an election to win!!
what's the timeline on the powel/rumsfield quotes? it would be interesting to see the time difference. when did each say those?
the economy IS doing well. the unemployment rate is the same now as it was when clinton was in office and everything was great back then, butnot now.
there are many jobs being moved out, but there are still PLENTY of unfilled jobs here. don't ask wher eyour insurance is, because it is YOUR job to get that. it is NOT the employer's responsibility to make sure you have health insurance. it is YOURS. if you refuse to get it, it is YOUR fault not mine, not Bush's
the stem cell research idea is interesting, because the democrats were ranting aboutbush not allowing it, or not funding it, or anythinglike that. (one of the reagan kids especially) yet there IS funding for that research in federal budget....just not embryonic.....
but your implication is that the money should be spent on you and your job? am i getting that right? or did i mis-read that line above....
open the classifieds, get out the red pen, and start marking the help wanted section up. put a red X on the jobs you are not willing to do.
if there are any red Xs on the page, then i'm done with this convo point. if you WANT to work there are jobs out there.
i'll work at mcdonalds if i have to. there's no shortage of jobs like that. might not pay great, but it's better than nothing.
empathy is one thing, and that's fine. understand the enemy. i think i do. they respond to one thing, violent force. that's their currency, that's the language the speak. we won't be sitting down for tea with them and working out our differences....they'll kill us as soon as look at us.
i guessi don't get the whole mindset of absolute blind seething hatred. and that's all i can see as the reason for most of the disagreements. for the tone in washington. sad.
oh, yeh. the military thing. not sure if it can really be called clinton's military. when i got out, our funding was going up, we could actually start to get parts and things fixed again, unlike the 90s. recruitment numbers went up, we started geting more people. dunno about other branches, maybe HDL and others can chime in. but navy we were starting to recover from the severe bloodletting the military took under clinton's watch. but still, it was the congress that cut our budget, and it was the secdef at the time that caved under pressure to let them cut us off. final approval was clinton, but he did none of the actual planning or the cuts that killed us. He, like bush, just signed the budget in to law....
but what do i know, i'm just a backwoods ignorant tennessee redneck hick, hey ya'll watch this!!
|
jonwright

Needs a job
Posts: 2416
|
posted September 23, 2004 05:03 PM
Edited By: jonwright on 23 Sep 2004 18:06
Who said I hated Bush? You did. You asked for examples of where I think he's gone wrong, and I have. I'm sure he's fun for a couple of drinks and a couple of lines of coke.
The comment about jobs - how the hell did that come into MY particular job? I'm talking about trends and also tax incentives et. al. My point was that if I have no job I will not be able to afford private insurance.
And I guess you are right - if someone has to work at McDonald's - fuck 'em. Tough shit. I got mine - that's your problem.
The unemployment rate is an interesting note - but notice that I said 'jobs created' which would naturally affect the unemployment rate. If new jobs are indeed created - such as a janitorial job, that 'replaced' a programming job - then the net would obviously be zero.
I didn't say the unemployment rate is horrible or that there aren't any jobs. Not my argument.
Powell's comments were before the war in front of the UN, and Rumsfeld was after the invasion and we weren't finding any WMD's. Pretty simple timeline.
Your examples of abuses of the Patriot Act:
1. So if there aren't abuses then that means it's okay? C'mon. Why do they need to look at publication and wire tap info on folks without a warrant?
And you can get any instances because the gov't can do those in secret without warrants or due process - so who would know to protest? And the info is not subject to FMOIA, either.
A crappy law that is SUBJECT to abuse does not warrant proof that is a bad law.
And I do hold Bush responsible for that law because his admin pretty much wrote the thing - right? Wasn't Ashcroft one of the primary authors? And yeah, I know congress gets to put in their pork barrell spending stuff as well.
The example of Clinton being held responsible for folks being shot: that wasn't due to a law that his administration crafted. Reno stood up and said that she was responsible - that she made the decision. And the officers involved with that were prosecuted I believe.
Do I remember correctly that Louis Freeh was rather let go after that? A report came out about the many break downs in the FBI.
quote: it's funny, even Kerry agreed with and wholly supported bush's actions last year.... but this year there's an election to win!!
Yup - in a tone of bi-partisanship they gave Bush the AUTHORITY to go to war as a bargaining chip. I supported that as well. We basically told Bush - 'we trust you - now go do what you must.' In the days after 9/11 who was going to question?
He did in Afghanistan. I think that was the right thing to do. No question.
I haven't heard any criticism for the actions in Afghanistan from anybody. Have you?
But I, and I think many Americans, feel hoodwinked on Iraq. There were states that were much more involved in terrorism than Saddam. Why didn't we start with Syria? Iran? Saddam was a fly on our ass - at least we knew where he was and he could keep our eye on him.
So here's the deal. I feel like after 9/11 we all said, "Go do what is right" and here's what I feel I have to show for it:
1. A quagmire in a country that has dubious evidence of state sponsored terrorism as well as dubious evidence of WMD when there are other states that WERE the Axis of Evil (that evidently aren't that evil anymore).
BUT - I'm cool with Afghanistan. We should have hooked a turn and kept going in Syria.
2. Our unilateral action on our own (because of reason #1) the world has rather turned their backs on us. And then we wonder why other folks hate us - it's okay for US to kill other folks.
3. Natural born Americans held in prisons without due process.
4. Profiling due to 'security' measures that violate equal protection under the law.
The fundamental reasons this country was founded - oppression in England - guilty until proven innocent - is being supplanted by pieces of totalitarianism under the guise of 'security.'
Hey, isn't that what the Iraquis are saying? "Yeah, Saddam sucked but at least we were safe."
Yeah - my name is NOT Hussein Islam but you know, with stuff like that the rules can change pretty quickly. Just ask any Russian you might know.
And as I'm sure Dino will appreciate - much like the argument about the second amendment - it's a slippery slope.
Especially when no one is watching over the gov't.
Libertarian sczicho? Perhaps.
|
addisonzx12
Expert Class
Posts: 213
|
posted September 23, 2004 05:24 PM
Some very good points JW!
|
slug

Pro
Out in search of my mind...
Posts: 1433
|
posted September 23, 2004 07:27 PM
you obviously miss the whole generic use of 'your' etc...
well when *I* use that terminology
justlike the hatred of bush comments, they are generic, because that's the overiding attitude in america, well, the really loudparts of america anyway.
when YOU use generic terms "who pays for my insurance, where does my paycheck come from" it's all ok....
double standard....
the example of clinton etc....Bush's admin came up with the law, fine. so bush is the failure when that law would get misused....he's to blame for his administration
clinton's admin admitted they screwed up, it wasn't clinton's fault.. fine, i can accept that
but wait..double standard again... clinton gets a pass for actions of his administration, but bush doesn't...oops
damned double standards!! get you every time
Bush admin and swift boat vets both used same lawyer for legal advice. heaven forbid!! those evil republians have ties to the swift boat vets! kill them all!! swift boat vets are all bush's fault!!
Kerry's campaign and moveon.org also share legal advisors....but hey, there's no connection. that is purely ok.
another double standard!!!
if bush, therefore evil. if kerry, therefore good.
1. quagmire? great word. you know if i remember correctly, we lost more troops in one day TRAINING for D-Day than we lost in iraq in the first year......
but i refer you to talk to HDL, or kawachan, or anyone else who has actually served over there, because i really don't think EITHER of us are qualified to make a judgment, especially to support your quagmire claims.
to me, a quagmire speaks of a situation that is totally untenable. complete, or near complete losses, no advances, no accomplishment of goals. if you have information that supports that, then please share it. but, watch your little slippery slope....as i would dare say that many of the actual servicemembers would refute your claims.
your comments basically say they are a failure...and a coherent look at the accomplishments and the things done so far reveals a MUCH more positive picture. but positive for America means bad for Kerry. so everything must be doom & gloom.
2.
the "unilateral" action...what amazes me is the CONTINUED blind repeating of that statement. please define unilateral....i think it has something to do with going at stuff alone.
the "world" has turned their backs on us
IF your definition of the "world" is france, germany, russia, north korea, china, and iran, then you're right.....
none of the coalition are part of the world though. we are going it alone. great observation i missed it!!
this comment is SO arrogant it isn't even funny. i am glad we don't have a lot of foreign members on this board, they'd be happy to be dismissed as noone....
3. you can say that, but where are your examples, i asked for them, because i truly WANT to have some real data to support my dislike of that particular bill. please pay attention instead of assuming... I WANT REAL EXAMPLES for my own use, andhave had no luck. since i have no proof, i don't spread rumours. i'll wait until i have good honest proof....IF YOU HAVE SOME PLEASE share
4. again, please, supply sources of real data, and not just hearsay. conspiracy theories are not enough here. these are serious charges.
see above on #3
The iraqi's that cnn and see-bs trot out say that, but again, talk to people that have actually BEEN there and see the difference....
don't take my word for it. this site has some things that show both how dangerous, and how much progress exists in iraq....
http://blog.ardemgaz.com/blog/
i've been reading it since it was linked by ( i think) vincent (thankyou very much for that link!) . some very cool stories there. and some things that make you think about what difference there is between the media reports and the people who are there.
yes, there are terrorist attacks, but since the USA has been in iraq, in the year and a half, we have yet to have seen even a small fraction of the deaths of iraqis or coalition troops that hussein perpetrated in 1988....
i have asked for evidence of abuses several times, because i DO want to keep an eye onwhat the government is doing. but you have yet to produce anything other than just words and accusations. thank you for helping your cause.
i have to work tomorow, and no idon't think that 'since i have my job screw McDs workers, but if they are happy there, then who am i to argue?
if they aren't happy, then look for something else. i knowlots of people who started out at McDs or Hardees or whatnot. lots of kids work there as first jobs. that's fine and dandy for entry level, or in-a-pinch jobs. and if you're good enough, management can be had as well, and you can make some decent money, even at mcdonalds.
don't be so quick to disdain a job at fast food, so many people are unwilling to do that yet it'll keep the bills paid if the person has a good head for their budget....
i'll dig up kerry's speeches and such in congress and other places, that show his support for removal of hussein, without the hemming & hawing that has been recently quoted to 'prove' that his stance hasn't really changed, and that he never *really* meant to remove hussein.....
|
deathpulse

Pro
Posts: 1688
|
posted September 24, 2004 05:14 AM
Bush rules!!! GO BUSH!!
|
|
|
|
|