fish_antlers

Administrator
The Truth is Out There
Posts: 21896
|
posted May 26, 2004 06:02 AM
Beans... hey.. it's a legit question with a real answer.... (not that I can remember how to solve it... ) .. but that's what you're here for!
____________
What business is it of yours where I'm from, Friendo?
|
beansbaxter
Needs a life
Posts: 5911
|
posted May 26, 2004 12:23 PM
Edited By: beansbaxter on 26 May 2004 15:41
That's cool fish, just making sure.
|
beansbaxter
Needs a life
Posts: 5911
|
posted May 26, 2004 02:41 PM
Fish...hey I need to know something about the material's shear resistance as the projectile piece will have to gouge out a hole in the hole piece...seriously, it wouldn't fit without forcing it, and it gets REALLY complicated once you get to that point. Might be able to model it with a computer, but not solving it analytically.
|
fish_antlers

Administrator
The Truth is Out There
Posts: 21896
|
posted May 26, 2004 03:36 PM
that would be cheating.. I know you'll have to force it and I also understand that one or the other or both of the objects would experience some "deflection" ... if you need to substitute a material you have more data about, that's cool.. I just picked Iron just 'cuz.
BTW.. dont ask me to solve this.. I stopped thinking about physics years ago.
____________
What business is it of yours where I'm from, Friendo?
|
frEEk

Administrator
ummm... yeah
Posts: 9660
|
posted May 26, 2004 04:42 PM
quote: I stopped thinking about physics years ago.
umm... don't you mean thinking PERIOD?
|
beansbaxter
Needs a life
Posts: 5911
|
posted May 26, 2004 05:02 PM
Edited By: beansbaxter on 26 May 2004 18:14
The calculations would totally depend on the material. It's too dyanamic to calculate manually. If A and B were made of the same materials, both A and B will start to bend. No matter what its made of, the shape of both objects will change if you are using the same materials for both.
|
fish_antlers

Administrator
The Truth is Out There
Posts: 21896
|
posted May 26, 2004 05:16 PM
I dont believe both objects would "bend".... lets say object b was 200 cm thick, but keep the rest of the dimensions for both the same. Object A would perhaps deform uniformly and the take on the shape of the round hole? in otherwords it would become a cyclinder, displacing it's corner mass to the sides? Hmmm... I suppose the first thing we need to do is calculate the volume of the hole in object B and the volume of A.
What would happen if object A was left as it is,l but object B was only 2 mm thick? Would object A remain "square" and the hole would become a square?
The remifications of this are interesting, both in physics, and in interpersonal relations!
____________
What business is it of yours where I'm from, Friendo?
|
beansbaxter
Needs a life
Posts: 5911
|
posted May 26, 2004 08:34 PM
.999.... DOES indeed = exactly 1.
easiest way to see this (but not a proof)
1/3 = .33333333...
1/3 = .33333333...
1/3 = .33333333...
Add them up... 1/3 + 1/3 + 1/3 = 1.
Or, from calculus, consider it .9 + .09 + .009 + .0009 + ...
= 9/10 + 9/100 + 9/1000 + 9/10000 + ...
that would be a geometric series, ratio 1/10.
sum = first term divided by (1 - ratio)
so, 9/10 divided by (1 - 1/10)
or 9/10 divided by 9/10 = 1.
|
beansbaxter
Needs a life
Posts: 5911
|
posted May 26, 2004 08:41 PM
Edited By: beansbaxter on 26 May 2004 21:42
quote: I dont believe both objects would "bend".... lets say object b was 200 cm thick, but keep the rest of the dimensions for both the same. Object A would perhaps deform uniformly and the take on the shape of the round hole? in otherwords it would become a cyclinder, displacing it's corner mass to the sides? Hmmm... I suppose the first thing we need to do is calculate the volume of the hole in object B and the volume of A.
What would happen if object A was left as it is,l but object B was only 2 mm thick? Would object A remain "square" and the hole would become a square?
The remifications of this are interesting, both in physics, and in interpersonal relations!
It's more than just that, the calculations are literally too complicated to solve analytically, even if you did have all the information. Differential equations can get mighty tricky, mighty fast.
This sort of experiment is best performed rather than modeled.
My first thoughts on this was that the amount of force necessary is all but negligible. (let's call it a net force)
You stand there with your round hole, and wait a while. I'm going to head to the other side of the galaxy and exert an unimaginably small net force on the square peg, causing it to accelerate ever so slightly in the direction of you. A few thousand light years later, I'll have that sucker moving at 90% the speed of light, using a VERY VERY small force.
Hmmmm, on second thought, that might be too fast. I'd be creating blackholes and all sorts of the other things that quantum physicists dream about. Note, when the new particle accelerator is completed in 2007, one of the expectations is that by colliding protons and anti-protons, they're hoping to create little tiny black holes...this would be the first analytical evidence in support of string theory.
After those initial thoughts, I thought about it some more and if you're working with more brittle materials, example: a solid piece of chalk, or maybe some ceramic materials, I think you'd only need to know the compressive and sheer strengths of the material.
Then again, I remember one experiment from glass science. We tested the sheer strength of cylindrical glass rods, about 4 cm long, with a diameter of perhaps 1/2 a cm. I recall that there was a HUGE variation in the strengths of the rods. Those who held them in their hands longer had introduced a lot of surface scratches and etching from the pH of their sweat in their hands. So, not only the material is going to come into play, but also the manufacturing process for that material, the microstructure of the material, and surface defects. That ought to make it way too difficult right there. I think the best you could do, even experimentally, is come up with a reasonable range of values, rather than an actual value. And, that range may be small or large, depending on the material used.
|
frEEk

Administrator
ummm... yeah
Posts: 9660
|
posted May 27, 2004 04:25 PM
quote: .999.... DOES indeed = exactly 1.
easiest way to see this (but not a proof)
1/3 = .33333333...
1/3 = .33333333...
1/3 = .33333333...
Add them up... 1/3 + 1/3 + 1/3 = 1.
well that's certainly a simple proof. i'd guess the best way to look at it is that .9bar doest exist. it's a nonsensical number. kind of like the guy who recently suggested there is no such thing as a "moment" in time. solves alot of problems, altho it's a little hard to grasp or beleive in a way.
|
zzzzzxxxxxr12

Expert Class
Posts: 214
|
posted May 27, 2004 05:09 PM
Edited By: zzzzzxxxxxr12 on 28 May 2004 11:13
hey beans, why should we believe that .9 = 1
I understand 1/3(3) =1
I also understand 1/3 = .33333333
But i also understand that .3333333(3)=.9999999
So doesnt that just prove that there is a fallacy in the system. And if this is so, why believe one outcome over the other.
|
oldkawboy

Needs a job
Posts: 2125
|
posted May 27, 2004 05:14 PM
Hey Bean....
Why do divers fall backwards from the side of a boat?
Dan (Born and raised in Port Angeles)
|
beansbaxter
Needs a life
Posts: 5911
|
posted May 27, 2004 05:30 PM
quote: Hey Bean....
Why do divers fall backwards from the side of a boat?
Dan (Born and raised in Port Angeles)
Port Angeles...where are you at now oldkawboy? Dang I didnt know there were others here in the beautiful Pacific NW.
|
beansbaxter
Needs a life
Posts: 5911
|
posted May 27, 2004 05:31 PM
quote: hey beans, why should we believe that .9 = 1
I understand 1/3(3) =1
I also understand 1/3 = .33333333
But i also understand that .3333333(3)=.9999999
So doesnt that just prove that there is a falacy is the system. And if this is so, why believe one outcome over the other.
I'm gonna pass this one off to frEEk...go get em boyeee!
|
oldkawboy

Needs a job
Posts: 2125
|
posted May 27, 2004 06:07 PM
I live right outside of Knoxville, TN at the base of Deals Gap!
I was in Port Angeles a couple years ago and will be going back for a long visit when I retire next year.
I love the Hurricane Ridge area and up to Neah Bay, which is on the opposite corner of the state from where you live. Beautiful country for sure!
Dan
|
fish_antlers

Administrator
The Truth is Out There
Posts: 21896
|
posted May 27, 2004 10:42 PM
Beans... I think you're straying from the subject and trying to avoid working out the answer. I never said you could take obect A to the other side of the universe. So... I'll add that information in...
Object A is resting on top of object B (lined up with the hole)
How much force is needed to drive object A through object B?
____________
What business is it of yours where I'm from, Friendo?
|
phingersniffer

Expert Class
Posts: 293
|
posted May 27, 2004 10:49 PM
"This sort of experiment is best performed rather than modeled"
Pussy
|
beansbaxter
Needs a life
Posts: 5911
|
posted May 28, 2004 11:56 AM
swft, spent some time this mornin workin on your first question (i'll do the second one later), but from your description it is still not clear to me what the equation should be like. I doubt one would start out with only one equation though.
Maybe you could give some more background or some more info please?
|
beansbaxter
Needs a life
Posts: 5911
|
posted May 28, 2004 05:33 PM
hey swft...are you avoiding my question?
|
frEEk

Administrator
ummm... yeah
Posts: 9660
|
posted May 28, 2004 06:23 PM
quote:
quote: hey beans, why should we believe that .9 = 1
I understand 1/3(3) =1
I also understand 1/3 = .33333333
But i also understand that .3333333(3)=.9999999
So doesnt that just prove that there is a falacy is the system. And if this is so, why believe one outcome over the other.
I'm gonna pass this one off to frEEk...go get em boyeee!
lazy
first of all let me prefix this by saying that i dont remember much of what i learned in math classes at uni (seeing as how i slept thru half of them plus have a horrible memory), plus since i took engineering and not pure math, my understanding of math is more practical than philosophical, for lack of a better word. in short, i'm hardly an authority on the subject. my answer will simply be my take on the issue and couple quite possibly change with further discussion or time.
regarding your point of why one over the other, i'd say because 1/3 is the definition of 0.3 (i'm gonna use the bar below instead of above since i have no other choice), we take that example as the correct answer.
following nicely from that point, is the question of whether the system is faulty. it's gonna be a yes & no kind of answer i think. it's faulty in that when we do .3*3 in our heads, we do it digit by digit, which of course produces .9, but i think that's our fault, not the systems. doing that calculation digit by digit is of course impossible because u never finish. the same is true of every geometric pattern; we never calculate them out, we have formulae [sp?] for alternate, non-infinite ways of calculating them. so simply put i'd say we simply treat any repeating number inaccurately, but that's jsut US, not the system. in damn near any real problem i'v ever faced, there aer countless assumptions of perfection, because otherwise it woudl take forever to calculate. it's like the highschool physics problems where we assume zero friction. i'd say our belief that we can calculate any repeating number digit by digit is simply an assumption we make for convenience' sake, but it doesnt always hold true. actually, a much more accurate way of describing it is probably by calling it a model, rather than an assumption. that is to say repeating numbers are a model, or perhaps even the decimal number system (meaning the abiity to have digits after the period, not Base 10) is just a model built as a convenient way of dealing with numbers, but like most if not all models, it includes a number of simplicications that don't work for every case. i'd say .9 is simply one of those cases where there is a bit of an non-intuitive exception to the rule.
so in short, .9 doesnt exist. the decimal system and the way we commonly use it just _suggests_ it does, but if u dig into the rules that define the system, it probably explicity states that it doesnt.
|
beansbaxter
Needs a life
Posts: 5911
|
posted May 28, 2004 09:08 PM
I couldnt have typed it better myself.
|
zzzzzxxxxxr12

Expert Class
Posts: 214
|
posted May 28, 2004 10:22 PM
Edited By: zzzzzxxxxxr12 on 29 May 2004 13:42
Freek i accept that with no problem. I guess the question that comes out this whole, and for some reason i never really questioned it before is:
Doesnt the example problem above show that a simple number in Fraction form identifies a measurement with accuracy that the decimal system struggles with?
|
beansbaxter
Needs a life
Posts: 5911
|
posted May 28, 2004 11:33 PM
quote: Doesnt the example problem above show that a simple number in Fraction form identifies a measurement with accuaracy that the decimal system struggles with?
hmmm....
|
beansbaxter
Needs a life
Posts: 5911
|
posted May 28, 2004 11:37 PM
Entropically Challenged
Uncontrollable subatomic event are said to be random. Every molecule is directly and factually affected by those whch came before it, producing a highly calculable stream of entropy. If we could produce a machine to monitor and analyze the innards and transactions of every quark in a region, chaos would cease to be; the process of living itself would be rendered sterile.
How many ATP molecules are required to lift a finger?
|
frEEk

Administrator
ummm... yeah
Posts: 9660
|
posted May 29, 2004 10:35 AM
quote: Doesnt the example problem above show that a simple number in Fraction form identifies a measurement with accuaracy that the decimal system struggles with?
I suppose that's a fair statement. Seems to me that "bar" syntax is essentially a convenient kludge to make the issue possible to grasp in most situations. But there are plenty of textbook examples of numbers that simply can not be represented in decimal format, such as pi. so yeah, i guess the decimal system is simply faulty by design.
|
|
|