beansbaxter
Needs a life
Posts: 5911
|
posted May 06, 2004 09:04 AM
It seems to me that you're achieving incredible precision on a small scale by generalizing the Earth as a perfect sphere. As I look at the curvature of the Earth out of class here, I notice that after about 3 hundred yards, it curves sharply uphill. Also, as far as gravity goes, gravity isn't constant across the surface of the earth. Nor is it constant across the surface of the ocean.
If you were to build you a 1 mile long ramp , and position it so that the center of the ramp was parallel to the gravitational field at the point where the center of the ramp was, I'm not 100% positive that a frictionless ball placed on one end of the frictionless ramp would necessarily roll toward the center. What if the end of the ramp was against the base of a cliff?
Or you can draw a big circle on paper and then put a square around it, touching on all four sides. Each side is your board. Now draw a big X touching each corner of the square. These lines represent the direction gravity will pull you. Now if you place a ball bearing or something at the corner of the square you'll see gravity doesn't pull at a right angle to the surface. It pulls to one side. Hence the ball will roll. It's nothing to do with the strength of gravity (try drawing the square inside the circle instead to think about that one).
By the way, the twin towers were tall enough that the they were measurably not perfectly parallel to each other by about ~11cm or something like that.
|
frEEk

Administrator
ummm... yeah
Posts: 9660
|
posted May 06, 2004 09:30 AM
beans, absolutely true about gravity not being perfectly equal. all mass generates gravity (yes, i know that statement in itself isnt correctly phrased), so a mountain or a valley etc will all affect the results. but we're talking about a generic quastion so we have to assume perfectly generic parameters, which is a smooth, round sphere. i used the radius at the equator in calculating it which of course is only accurate when placing your borad on the equator. but given that we were assuming a frictionless surface, i kinda took the other assumptions to be fair game as to your example of putting the high end off the board next to the base of, say everest, it may infact no roll due to the direction of gravity being slightly shifted there. if it's enough tho, i'm not sure. everest may be pretty massive, but it's pretty puny compared to the earth as a whole.
|
beansbaxter
Needs a life
Posts: 5911
|
posted May 06, 2004 08:51 PM
quote: beans, absolutely true about gravity not being perfectly equal. all mass generates gravity (yes, i know that statement in itself isnt correctly phrased), so a mountain or a valley etc will all affect the results. but we're talking about a generic quastion so we have to assume perfectly generic parameters, which is a smooth, round sphere. i used the radius at the equator in calculating it which of course is only accurate when placing your borad on the equator. but given that we were assuming a frictionless surface, i kinda took the other assumptions to be fair game as to your example of putting the high end off the board next to the base of, say everest, it may infact no roll due to the direction of gravity being slightly shifted there. if it's enough tho, i'm not sure. everest may be pretty massive, but it's pretty puny compared to the earth as a whole.
Wait a second. If we assume a frictionless surface, the ball will NOT roll. It will slide.
I did a quick (rough, and possibly has an error, since I didn't draw much of a diagram) calculation for the force on a 100kg ball 1.0 kilometers away from the point where the "ramp" is perpendicular to the direction of earth's gravity (assuming a perfectly spherical earth, etc). Using 6350 km as the radius of the earth, I calculated a force of .15 Newtons parallel to the "ramp"
980Newtons * sin(arctan(1km/6350km)
Of course, my method of calculation isn't perfect, since it neglects the greater distance from the center of the earth. Nonetheless, the difference is far far less than the precision of my acceleration 9.80 m/s^2
The actual weight would be .9999999752*the original weight.
Assuming a spherical Mount Everest, mass 5x10^10 kg (googled it), and that the distance from the center to be approximately3 km (a guess), using Gm1m2/r^2, I calculated a force of around 40 Newtons??.
oh sh!t. I forgot to change it to meters. Damn it!
make that 3.7 x 10^-5 Newtons.
Mountain isn't enough to stop it if it's frictionless. However, if it's frictionless, as I said above, it won't roll, it'll slide.
Well, I was almost about to calculate the velocity of the ball as it passed the center of the ramp, but I'm done procrastinating something else now.
|
dougmeyer

Needs a job
moderated
Posts: 2713
|
posted May 06, 2004 09:36 PM
All very interesting. I think.....
If the surface of the board is always equidistant from the center of the earth i.e., (yielding a curved board) the ball just sits, of course. Given that the center of the gravitational force lies at the center of the mass, and that the mass is a true sphere, the force vector goes to that center. But if the board is flat, the ends of the board become relatively "uphill" from the center of mass (and "pull") and the ball rolls to the center where the board contacts the sphere (earth).
The turn & slip indicator in an airplane (that little curved glass tube with the black ball in it) is a very simple and precise indicator of this. When that ball is at the low point of the curved tube, all is right with the world. Roll the airplane off level while keeping the nose on a point and that little ball always stays "down" with great sensitivity.
Doug
|
necro

Needs a job
My Grandma Is A Virgin
Posts: 2148
|
posted May 06, 2004 09:39 PM
Nah, I don't want to think right now. I do that at work.
Things are not what they seem...
____________
3829
|
DB

Pro
Posts: 1932
|
posted May 06, 2004 10:10 PM
This thread is taking way too many brain cells
____________
Dan
04 ZX10r (Track only)
08 Concours14
|
ozzy

Needs a job
need guberment cheese
Posts: 3172
|
posted May 07, 2004 04:46 AM
So if all this brain talk is true then an object that is standing still is setting on top of the curvature.
If that is true then the salt flats aren't level, but are indeed a curved surface and Doug went downhill! LOL.
Good to see you back on the board Doug.
Beens you need to stay away from Webster Hall and stop setting behind gas stations thinking about this crap.
|
Hells Dark Lord

Needs a life
living life, and loving it.
Posts: 7981
|
posted May 07, 2004 05:04 AM
my brain hurts....
____________
When in doubt, lean farther and go faster....
|
zxfingyz
Expert Class
Posts: 424
|
posted May 07, 2004 07:12 AM
Thank God for guy like you's. It is converstations like this that have caused me to meet so many girls at the next table in bars. "s'cuse me miss? Can you help me not commit justifiable homicide? My gay cousins here are talking about physics..."
|
swft

Needs a life
Full throttle!
Posts: One MEEEEEELLION
|
posted May 07, 2004 07:19 AM
Actually, Beans has not considered unified field theory, wherein the very fabric of the universe distorts around 'pools' of mass. So nothing is ever truly 'level'.
|
beansbaxter
Needs a life
Posts: 5911
|
posted May 07, 2004 11:58 AM
unified field theory...more to think 'bout i see
|
|
|
|
|