posted May 02, 2004 06:30 AM
Edited By: canadamaxxer on 2 May 2004 12:28
Ran the 1270 on the Dyno.... Well, I finally got a company(Thunder Cycle in Okotoks, Alberta) to build me a map for my 1270 combo. It took a few hours and about 12 runs on their Factory Pro EC 997, but the bike is now tuned. It posted a best run of 157.5 HP (true horspower) and 92 lb/ft of torque (true torque). These are the highest numbers they have ever seen on their dyno (all motor). Keep in mind that this is without the dynojet horsepower fudge factor...multiply those numbers by 1.22 to get the dynojet horsepower: 192.15 HP and 112 lb/ft of torque. Horsepower peaks around 10,500 rpm, and torque peaks at 7,500 rpm. I have ridden it and it is so fast and soooo smooth. I just roll the throttle on and the front end lifts at 7500 rpm. All in all I am very happy and now am patiently waiting to be able to put the stroker crank in the engine (next year???).
posted May 02, 2004 06:57 AM
what are you talking about with the fudge factor? maybe that's why I was getting low Hp when I dynoed my bike got about 158 hp and was pissed.
posted May 02, 2004 07:15 AM
Go to the Factory Pro website and read up on "true Horsepower" vs Dynojet Horsepower. Basically the concept is that the method used by DJ is flawed and that their readings are artifically high. This is, of course, debatable and the bottom line is that in order for there to be a fair comparison, you would have to run multiple bikes on the same dyno with the same air temp/humidity/ baro pressure to get a fair comparison. I know that a stock ZX12 ran about 137 hp on that same dyno, and the hottest busa these guys ever had opportunity to play with ran about 142 hp. They ran a Gixxer 1000 on the dyno ...on the bottle....and he pulled low 170's. Relative to those other bikes, mine is VERY strong. Unfortunately all these bike ran on different days, so we'll never really know for sure. We'll see on the track I guess.
BTW: HDL......Oh, I do enjoy it!!!!! The shriek of the Ti Hindle can is music to my ears and the knowledge that I ran an honest 270km/h yesterday (speedo corrected for the gearing change and the 8% error) and had about 2500 rpm left to the red line.....makes me smile. 300 km/h???? I don't think it will be a problem.
posted May 02, 2004 08:20 AM
I would say that your fudge factor sounds about right. 192 HP for a 1270 kit is about average from what I hear. Congrats and enjoy.
posted May 02, 2004 09:59 AM
Edited By: zx12richard on 2 May 2004 11:01
Not sure I buy the factory pro bullshit... A ZX12 was 178 at the crankshaft and with a 15%(maybe not quite that much) lose thru drivetrain would be 151.3 horsepower stock...
These numbers have been seen on dynojet dynos...
Your numbers are 157.5. + 15%= 181.12... So your 1270 gained you 3.12 horsepower at crank from stock... Using the factory crank numbers..
May be wrong but just my thoughts until someone can teach me different..
posted May 02, 2004 11:27 AM
Richard, It really doesn't matter whether you buy it or not. You might consider reading the whole thread and the information on the factory pro website before calling bullshit. Factory Pro is claiming a 21-22% variation between true horspower and "Dynojet horsepower". That is where I got the number of 1.22 as a multiplier. The information on the website is there for you to read if you'd just take the time. From my perspective, I really don't care what the numbers are...relative to some dyno in Florida, or Hawaii or France or whereever. Until there is a universally accepted method of calculating horsepower and torque, there is no fair comparison. It's just a dick measuring contest anyways...dynojet is using a centimeter ruler and calling it an inch ruler to measure their dicks and then wowing all of us with the numbers of how well hung they are....until we all get to whip it out in public and see......
A dyno is a tool....not to measure horsepower for horsepower sake, but to measure horsepower to make changes and see if there is an improvement or not, as compared to the baseline run. I went to this shop to get a map made for my unusual combination.....and put down the strongest numbers they've ever seen. That number was 157.5 HP. I guess that means that those 180 HP power commander and pipe bikes are faster than my 1270, with porting, etc. I guess we'll just have to wait and see.
posted May 02, 2004 11:30 AM
Forget the dyno.... what mph does it run at the track?
____________
Official Charter Member of the RIDERS OF KAWASAKI MEMBERSHIP REVOCATION CLUB
Also a BadAss Internet Forum Moderator 4 Hire!! Come at me brah!
posted May 02, 2004 11:44 AM
Edited By: zx12richard on 2 May 2004 12:46
My point is 178 stock at crank.... Whats it measured with??? The dynojet numbers my not be dead on but they add up with a 15% hp drop from factory claimed numbers..... What do they dyno the motors at the factory on when they measure at crank horsepower???
I understand dynos ALL read a bit different... But Factory Pro is way different...
Numbers don't add up to stock crank numbers to me...
If a bike is measure at the crank at 178 and with the 14.5% drop they(factory pro)claim to rear wheel they should have a reading of roughly 152.19 hp to rear wheel.. Theirs(factory pro) is way off that number.. My very first dyno run was around 153 I believe on a 150 dj dyno... Seems thats where they should be minus 14.5% drop as claimed by factory pro to rear wheel.. If the crank numbers are correct...
So are they 178 crank numbers off???? The numbers just don't add up....
posted May 02, 2004 11:55 AM
The assumption that the factory numbers are correct and not skewed by the marketing departments of the manufacturers is probably sadly incorrect.
Here is a copy of the Factory Pro website page titled "true Horsepower":
SNIP>
What is True Rear Wheel (tm) Horsepower?
The industry wide achievable standard
A Dynamometer can only measure actual power at the output location.
Actual power produced AND delivered by an vehicle will be highest if measured at the engine's crankshaft, lower at the transmission output shaft and even lower, but more meaningful, still, at the rear wheel.
The power that you use is the power at the rear wheel.
Some Dynamometer companies add to measured rear wheel power readings a factor that is based on ESTIMATED rear wheel power losses (under what power conditions? 125cc? 1200cc? under coasting conditions? with a 3.00x17 bias ply tire? a 190x17 radial tire? New heavy radial tire vs. worn old, light, stock bias ply tire? Who knows?)
In short, there is NO meaningful "average" tire to get a correct rear tire power transmission loss measurement for all bikes - so obviously, unless they actually measure the power lost in the rear tire, under driven load conditions, NO dyno company should BE ADDING incorrect power figures into the measured power. It's simply wrong.
The fact that they add varying amounts of power to the actual, "true" amount of power delivered and measured to the surface of the drive roller creates a situation that makes it an onerous task to compare power figures from different brands of dynamometer systems.
On simple inertial dynamometers, some (most, actually, all that I know of in the MC market) companies use an average for the inertial mass value of the engine, transmission, rear wheel, sprocket and chain on every bike - as if a YZ125 has the same rear wheel or internal rotating mass as a 1340cc Harley Davidson. Needless to say, if the software thinks that the YZ125 had a HD rear wheel on it, it would look like the 125 makes more HP at the rear wheel than it does at the crankshaft. It's simply wrong.
And - that's why you hear of 125cc Karts that make 43 hp at the rear wheels!!!!!
It's expensive to measure frictional losses in the engine and drivetrain, requiring the dyno to be able to drive the vehicle with engine off. Add the cost of a 50+hp electric motor, controlled power supply, etc. It's just not likely that $20,000 dyno will be equipped with that equipment.
It is also common for dynamometer companies to add to the power readings by adding transmission and primary gear/chain losses back into the measured power readings. Some companies make a concerted effort try to measure frictional losses and, optionally, add the power to the measured readings. Other companies - some that would surprise you - say that it's not important and give a blanket, single factor for frictional losses in every engine. That includes some $25,000-$35,000 dynes.
Some simply say that there is a meaningful "average" for every motorcycle,(2 stroke, 4 stroke, 1 cylinder/1 transmission, 4 cylinder/1 transmission) and apply it to every bike and that it is not a significant difference.
Blanket estimates of "average" losses and corrections are, quite simply, incorrect. At the upper levels of the industry, (we are talking about $150,000 - $500,000 AC or DC 4 quadrant dynamometers) it is not tolerated - shouldn't be - and needn't be.
There is a dyno company that actually has different versions of software that displays their own identical data files as different amounts of power depending on whether you use the DOS version or the Windows version of their software!!
True Rear Wheel Horsepower (tm) is Factory Pro's standard of measuring the power that is actually delivered to the rear wheel. It is honest, true, fair and duplicable. It is the ONLY standard that can be duplicated by the entire industry - regardless of the dyno manufacturer.
Following is a reference table so that, if you are used to rather inflated HP figures, you can see what your vehicle would generally make on the True HP Scale.
250cc Street specific comment general comment All figures SAE Corrected
Aprilia 250, street, 2 stroke Aprilia Series all stock class ~ 48 - 52 True HP
Aprilia 250, production racer, 2 stroke Modified engine / comp. exhaust
(Desmoto / San Francisco, CA) 250cc Superstreet class ~61-62 True HP
(best EVER seen!)
Kaw, ex250, stock all stock, ~3k miles . ~ 25 - 28 True HP
Kaw, ex250, prod racer modified engine, stk exh 32 is pretty good ~ 32 - 35 True HP
250cc Gran Prix specific comment general comment All figures SAE Corrected
RR, xxxxxxx, 250 GP ex factory.... you wish.... :-) ~82+ True HP
RR, Honda, rs250,98, kitted pretty good one. rs's have great midrange (9k-11k) power. Similar powerband as 00-01 TZ ~66-70 True HP
70 was "kitted"
RR, Honda, rs250,98, stockish . rs's have great midrange power ~64-68 True HP
RR, Yam, tz250,00-02, not even close to stockish . . ~74-76 True HP
(on a "good" day)
RR, Yam, tz250,00-01, stockish . 00-01 tz's have great 9k-10k power, and a bit less topend than a kitted 96 model ~65-70 True HP
RR, Yam, tz250,91-98, stockish . pre 2000 tz's have great high rpm power ~64-70 True HP
RR, Yam, tz250,96, kitted really good one. pre 2000 tz's have great high rpm power, peaky compared to RS and 00-01 TZ ~69-73 True HP
72-73 was "kitted"
Factory Pro's 4 Gas EC997 is the single, most popular dyno used by AMA Pro 250 race teams and racers - Including Chuck Sorensen's AMA #1 Aprilia 250, Simon Turner's Priority Racing TZ250 and Roland Sands Performance Machine's Daytona 250 lap record breaker TZ250 and Rich Oliver's TZ250.
In addition, 250 Privateers overwhelmingly choose the EC997 as a primary source of meaningful tuning information.
Yep - that was us dynoing in the dark at Road America at 10:30pm and again at Virginia International.........
600cc Street specific comment general comment All figures SAE Corrected
600, Hon, cbr600 fi, 01
mod unrestricted version FI
w/ comp exhaust Excellent midrange, pretty good topend. ~88-92 True HP
600, Honda, cbr600 f4, 99-00,
mod unrestricted version,
w/ pipe, 1.7-RK jet, advance stock, unmodified engine-> ~87-92 True HP
600, Hon, cbr600 f4, 99-00, stock CA version / restricted Excellent midrange, not so good topend, install 49 state / unrestricted cams AND Igniter unit to convert to unrestricted ~72-75 True HP
600, Hon, cbr600 f4, 99-00, stock unrestricted version Excellent midrange, OK topend. ~78-83 True HP
600cc Street specific comment general comment All figures SAE Corrected
600, Kaw, zx6r, 01-02
AMA race mod - best AMA Supersport
(best ever AMA - by 4&6 Cycle, 02) Blueprinted engine, AMA spec, w/ race fuel (2-3 hp) ~ 96-98 True HP
(almost unobtainable)
600, Kaw, zx6r, 01-02
AMA race mod - usual AMA Supersport
(common AMA) Blueprinted engine, AMA spec, w/ race fuel (2-3 hp) ~ 91-94 True HP
(obtainable with care)
600, Kaw, zx6r, 98-99, stock unrestricted version
(no hp restricted version in USA) Good midrange, good topend.
(Best CA hp 600) ~ 81-84 True HP
600, Kaw, zx6r, 98-99, unrestricted version
lots tested
w/ pipe, ,jet, advance Good topend, excellent midrange ~ 84-90 True HP
(exceptional 90hp was CA model w/ Remus street slipon! - 08/12/99)
600, Kaw, zx6r, 95-97, unrestricted lots tested
w/ pipe, ,jet, +6 advance Good topend, excellent midrange ~ 84-89.9 True HP
89.5hp was Team Kinkos backup 600 w/ Muzzy 5/95. 85-87hp is not uncommon.
600, Kaw, zx6e, 95-98, unrestricted lots tested
w/ pipe, ,jet, +6 advance is usually best Good topend, excellent midrange ~ 83-85 True RWHP
rare 87hp was w/ street slipon
600cc Street specific comment general comment All figures SAE Corrected
600, Suz, gsxr600,02
AMA spec According to Anthony, the engine was stock (it looked original) and was borrowed from a friend AMA bikes tested w/ race fuel 99.97 - 100.05 True HP
(Highest HP ever tested on AMA 600cc! 08/02 Virginia International Raceway AMA race)
600, Suz, gsxr600, 01-02
AMA spec (?) "AMA" spec - but...
I'm suspicious that it would pass tech AMA bikes tested w/ race fuel (2-3 hp) ~95-96 True HP
(rare)
600, Suz, gsxr600, 01-02
usual AMA spec "AMA" spec AMA bikes tested w/ race fuel (2-3 hp) ~91- 94 True HP
(not uncommon)
600, Suz, gsxr600, 96-99, mod lots tested
w/ pipe, ,1.7-RK jet, +4 advance stock, unmodified engine-> ~84-90 True HP
600, Suz, gsxr600, 97-00, stock unrestricted version stock, unmodified engine-> ~81-84 True HP
600, Suz, gsxr600, 97-00, stock CA version / restricted stock, unmodified engine
Replace cam / cams. ~73-77 True HP
600, Suz, Katana 600, 99 CA version / restricted stock, unmodified engine ~65-68 True HP
600cc Street specific comment general comment All figures SAE Corrected
600, Yam, yzf600 R6, 2003
mod all stock engine Factory Pro V Stacks
Hindle exhaust
Race fuel
stock fueling ~ 112 True HP
600, Yam, yzf600 R6, 2003
mod all stock engine Factory Pro V Stacks
Hindle exhaust
pump premium
stock fueling ~ 108 True HP
600, Yam, yzf600 R6, 2003
ALL STOCK
Jim @ Duc, Tri, Yam of Marin
415 45603345 all stock engine all stock ~ 93-95 True HP
600, Yam, yzf600 R6, to 02 Best HP on R6 -
Jamie Barkley's bike - Entered in HP limited class (!) in Canada, 01
w/ race fuel (2-3 hp) ~ 105 True HP
(best one tested and the quickest R6 in Canada, 2001)
600, Yam, yzf600 R6,to 02 Best "AMA" spec ever tested
AMA blueprint engine, stock v stacks AMA bikes tested w/ race fuel (2-3 hp) ~ 97.5 -98.5 True HP
(best one tested)
600, Yam, yzf600 R6, all to 01
tuned to max, best one. Highest hp stock engined 600 ever tested. +4 Advance, Y78-1.7-RK carb, V Stacks, stock air filter, aftermarket exhaust,
"maybe" AMA legal AMA bikes tested w/ race fuel (2-3 hp) ~ 96.5 -97.5 True HP
(best one tested)
600, Yam, yzf600 R6, all to 01
mod Usual True HP with +4 Advance, Y78-1.7-RK carb, V Stacks, stock air filter, aftermarket exhaust best hi rpm power, pump gas ~ 92-94 True HP
600, Yam, yzf600 R6, all to 01
mod unrestricted version,
race slipon race slipon usually adds 3 hp
pump gas ~ 89 - 92 True HP
600, Yam, yzf600 R6, all to 01
stock unrestricted, 15.5k redline
49 state / Euro best hi rpm power ~ 85 - 86 True HP
600, Yam, yzf600 R6, all to 01
stock CA / restricted version,
14k redline Unrestricted this bike - Cams and optionally, igniter box and +4 Advancer ~ 76 - 78 True HP
748cc Street specific comment general comment All figures SAE Corrected
748, Ducati 748 R, 00-01
w/ shower injectors modified engine mod, 120 minute engine w/ exhaust and race fuel (2-3 hp) ~102-105 True HP
(best ever!)
748, Ducati 748 R, 00-01
w/ shower injectors unmodified engine stock engine w/ exhaust and race fuel (2-3 hp) ~90-92 True HP
750cc Street specific comment general comment All figures SAE Corrected
gsxr750, 02,
AMA spec highest HP
AMA spec engine (?) best ever tested, probably pass tech....
inc. race fuel (2-3 hp) ~ 124.5 True HP
(cams and porting help streetbikes get here!)
gsxr750, 02,
AMA spec very good HP
AMA spec engine
Can win at any US track Very good
should pass tech....
w/ race fuel (2-3 hp) ~ 120 True HP
gsxr750, 02,
AMA spec common HP
AMA spec engine
can win at short track usual HP expected with no tuning mistakes.
Should pass tech....
w/ race fuel (2-3 hp) ~ 115 True HP
gsxr750, 02,
w/ stock engine w/ exhaust usual HP usual HP expected with no tuning mistakes. ~ 110-114 True HP
gsxr750, 00-02,
w/ comp exhaust all stock all stock ~ 106-108 True HP
(110true = 134 djhp 23% ???)
(115.9 true=138.9 djhp 20% ???)
gsxr750, 96-99,
mod street w/ comp exhaust, jet, +2 advance . ~ 102-104 True HP
gsxr750, 96-99,AMA Supersport usual AMA bikes make much better power at 8k - 11k ~ 102-110 True HP
(102-103 easy - 107-110 hard to get)
gsxr750, 98-99,AMA Supersport best ever tested . ~ 111.2 True HP
gsxr750, 00-01,
w/ comp exhaust . . ~ 106-108 True HP
(110true = 134 djhp 23%)
(115.9 true=138.9 djhp 20%)
900cc Street specific comment general comment All figures SAE Corrected
cbr900rr, stock . . ~ 97-98 True HP
cbr900rr, APK, pipe and +2 Advance, cam degree . . ~ 102-104 True HP
rf900 . . .
996cc Street specific comment general comment All figures SAE Corrected
996, Ducati 996
Les Oglesby extremely modified 996
(J. Hackett, Nash engine - final cam timing and FI tune Factory Pro, San Rafael) pump gas, exhaust ~125 True HP
(w/ 60mm throttle bodies)
996, Ducati 996
Les Oglesby extremely modified 996
(J. Hackett, Nash engine - final cam timing and FI tune Factory Pro, San Rafael) pump gas, exhaust ~119-120 True HP
(w/ std throttle bodies)
996, Ducati 996 stock engine pump gas, exhaust ~90-92 True HP
929cc Street specific comment general comment All figures SAE Corrected
cbr929 all stock all stock ~ 108-110 True HP
cbr929 w/ slipon Erion ~ 110 - 112 True HP
954cc Street specific comment general comment All figures SAE Corrected
cbr954 w/ slipon Erion ~ 117-120 True HP
1000cc Street specific comment general comment All figures SAE Corrected
Aprilia, Mille all stock all stock ~ 94 - 96 True HP
Aprilia, Mille w/ typical full system w/ pc ~ 100 - 102 True HP
Aprilia, Mille w/ typical full system w/ rsvz1413 chip ~ 102 - 104 True HP
gsxr1000, 01-03 all stock all stock ~ 121(lowest) - 129(highest)
gsxr1000, 01-03 w/ comp exhaust . ~ 138 - 140 True HP
yzf1000 R1,02 w/ stock exhaust. . ~ 116 - 118 True HP
yzf1000 R1,98-00 w/ stock exhaust . ~ 115.5 - 118.5 True HP
yzf1000 R1, 98-00 w/ full system most full sys's add 6-8 True HP ~ 122 - 124 True HP
1100cc Street specific comment general comment All figures SAE Corrected
cbr1100xx, stock exhaust . . ~ 126 - 128 True HP
cbr1100xx, competition exhaust . . ~ 132 - 136 True HP
zx11d, Mr. Turbo, 7.5psi boost low compression pistons . ~ 150 True HP
1300cc Street specific comment general comment All figures SAE Corrected
Hayabusa, stock exhaust . .at least 20 samples tested ~ 135 - 139 True HP
Hayabusa, slipon, race . .at least 20 samples tested ~ 142 - 145 True HP
Hayabusa, full system ~ 145 - 152 True HP
True HP as compared to DJHP
It's not possible to give an absolute conversion factor, as it appears that dj dynos don't all read the same (my experience, other's, too - and Mag Articles and 2002 Roadracing World gsxr1000 and R1 comparison articles), but, you can take True HP from EC997's and produce an "average" djhp of of an "average" dj dyno - empirically derived, over 12 years of comparison of the two hp scales.
True HP Scale DJHP +/- 2% multiplication factor
50 True HP 52.5(hi mass) to
57.5(low mass) *1.05 to 1.15 = djhp
(the dj dynos do not compensate for the differences in inertial mass of the bike - an HD/Cruiser has a heavier rear wheel, chain and crankshaft than a YZ 250 and the EC997 dyne systems are not affected by)
80 True HP 90 djhp *1.12 = djhp
90 True HP 103 djhp *1.15 = djhp
100 True HP 115 djhp *1.15 = djhp
120 True HP 138 djhp *1.15 = djhp
130 True HP 150 djhp *1.15 = djhp
140 True HP 168 djhp *1.20 = djhp
150 True HP 180 djhp *1.21 = djhp
I don't know what the scale is after 275 True or in between 160 True and 275, as I haven't tested any motorcycle engine that makes that much power.
275 True HP 375 djhp *1.35 = djhp
The 275 True was a supercharged flat 6 Porsche engine in a stretched ZX11 frame.
Example: You made 116 True HP and you want to know what that is in an average djhp number:
See above chart -
Locate at 110 and 120 True - they are both "*.1.15 = djhp" -
So take:
116 x 1.15 and multiply it - get and average 133.2 djhp +/- 2% reading.
Proper tuning, especially on high HP bikes, like gsxr1000's, ZX12's and Hayabusa's GREATLY affects the power difference.
Due to the fact that the dj dyno's sweep so quickly on sweep hp tests, they get the acc. map and the main maps to occur during the test, ending up over-rich, affecting the HP difference - For example, a ZX12, tuned to run fully loaded, with the Acc. map NOT triggered, will be too rich on a dj at full throttle and will be too rich, requiring leaning them out a fairly large amount to make best power (remember - fast acc triggers both Main Fuel and Acc. Maps working at same time).
The average HP conversion factors assume that the bike was leaned out and tuned for best power on an average dj dyno.
The other factor that needs to be taken into account is that dj dynos assume that every vehicle has the same rotating mass - they don't - and that disregard is another reason why the hp conversion figures are different. The EC997's can measure power in Steady State Mode (inertia is not a factor in power equation), the inertial mass changes on each bike affects the dj power, but not the True HP.
There's another message in the above example, besides the average THP to DJHP conversion factor -It's up to the more experienced reader to figure it out.
Chassis dyne HP
What is it? What to call it?
EC997 = "True HP"
Dynojet = "DJHP"
It's not really proper to call "djhp" "rwhp", as neither the EC997, dynojet, Fuchs, Superflow or Land and Sea will necessarily produce the same numbers as a dj dyno, except by luck - and the whole idea of True HP is that EVERY dyno manufacturer HAS the capability to provide those numbers!
The Superflow chassis dynes, the EC997's, Land and Sea and Mustangs are all capable of measuring power in steady state mode and producing the same numbers - they all measure:
torque x rpm / 5252 = horsepower
We've not diddled with physics!
The only factor that is added to the measured reading, in True HP Mode, is the additional energy (dyne parasitics) required to spin the dyno roller to whatever speed the roller is turning at - logical, proper and required for any measuring instrument,
torque x rpm / 5252 = horsepower + parasitic power = True HP
We've not diddled with physics and joined a power "puff" derby.
Whether they provide a number that is comparable to other dynes (like Factory Pro did), or not, is completely up to the manufacturer - some like to squirrel away their "puff factors" and some actually "lost" their source code and made up new ones that were 2% higher than the old DOS ones.
Chassis dyne HP
What can inflate HP readings on a dyno, but not really make more engine power in the real world?
A few things can affect HP when using inertia dynos (not a dyne in Steady State Mode) to measure power (what else would you do??:-):
Changing to a light, worn stock rear tire will improve power output on an inertia dyno, but, not improve real world top speed.
A heavier (brand new race) tire that replaced the above, light, worn tire, will decrease measured power on an inertia dyno, but not decrease real world top speed.
Lighter wheels are a good thing!
Better acc. in lower gears, esp. 1st and 2nd (accelerating less inertial mass!).
Better suspension is possible, too!
Flicks from side to side easier and hence, quicker in the "esses".
Riding hard on worn, light tires is foolish.
Problems with Inertia dyno test procedure and fuel injected vehicles:
A Sweep Test (hold throttle wide open and sweep from low rpm to high rpm) will often trigger the ACC. FUEL Map, along with the Main FUEL Map, causing the dyno operator to to lean out the main fuel map to compensate for the additional fuel the ACC. FUEL Map delivers. Of course, in the real world, upper gears, the acceleration rate of the engine is much slower than what they tested, doesn't trigger the ACC FUEL Map, and the bike ends up a lot leaner in reality in top gear.
It's not that common of a problem, since most people never ride that fast for that long to cause engine damage - but, the manufacturers will find out soon enough about that.
Work around:
Tune full throttle fueling in real world usage at dragstrip (to best trap speed) or in Steady State Mode on different dyno.
Chassis dyne HP
How can a bike with 132 djhp race and lead with bikes with 141 djhp at Daytona?
You can optimize tuning for a dj dyno and make big numbers - and you can tune the bike to make best power under load on an EC997 and blow off the big dj dyno numbers - That's what that happened at Daytona a couple of years ago...
132 djhp Jimmy Moore gsxr750 (115-116 True HP) lead Daytona CCS over 141djhp Team Suzuki's gsxr??? and Zlock Racing's ZX9 -
How? It's impossible to spot competitors 8 real hp and lead the last few laps until the drafting battle at the line on the last lap!
The answer is obvious (no - Jimmy's bike was legal - we didn't need to limit the power on it.... It was an end of the year experiment that went awry....)
The answer is obvious (read above rantings :-) and is just another example of non-real world power figures.
Can a tuner cheat and make an EC997 read higher?
The only way that could happen is in a Sweep Test - Sweep Tests are the least reliable of all tests. Period. Ours or others. There is NO question about that.
Since the Rotating Mass is a variable in a Sweep Test (NOT a Steady State Test! - where it's not a factor), the actual inertia factor entered affects the final HP figure - - Tell the software that the vehicle has a lot of rotating mass to accelerate, and the HP number increases. (torque, rpm, acc. rate and mass are the factors) - just like dj dyno ignoring the difference in mass of all bikes -
So - True HP, again -
Steady State Test - No acceleration, mass makes no difference, anymore. Torque, RPM and dyne parasitics. Period. True.
Can you make a Steady State Test (normal EC997 mode) read higher?
I can squeak, maybe, 1/2 HP extra out of an rpm point, at the most. I was curious (big surprise??) and I tried and tried - 1/2 True HP. That's about it. And that's pretty hard and you have to consciously try hard to do it - and you have to know how to do it -
The software will NOT take data unless speed and load are completely stable - eliminating cheating (the accuracy is hard coded into the program, so it can't be diddled with!)
As far as other dynos - and being able to make "flash readings" - that's now, ancient history on most newer dynes. Our dynes have always factored a base inertial mass factor to prevent "overloading" and resulting high hp "flash" readings - even in the Steady State Test.
I think that that's more possible in older manual controlled systems that happen to be water brake type engine dynos, but, I can't really talk much about them because I do not have recent firsthand experience.
As far as atmospheric conditions making a +/- 10% difference? Unless you really(!!!) mess with the barometric pressure (and you can look at every atmospheric factor on every test report sheet - it's hard coded to display - not an "option" to display, it is simply, absolutely impossible to do without obvious evidence.
Some dynamometers will actually display "actual HP" and not specify that it is "uncorrected" to standard air ("SAE Corrected", for example) - That shouldn't ever be given to a customer - The customer probably doesn't know that "actual" means "uncorrected" and that the results can't be compared to anybody else's dyno chart -
I saw a recent chart reading "Actual HP" instead of "SAE Corrected" HP - The testing facility had just installed an undercut transmission on a gsxr1000 and had somehow lost 10-15 djhp - They gave the customer a chart displaying "Actual HP" because it was 3-4 djhp higher than "SAE Corrected" - to try to hide some assembly error - They denied all responsibility.........
The moral? Sometimes the cheapest isn't the best deal - or an honest deal either -
Are final tuning optimal dyno settings different on an Inertia dyno vs. an EC997
For many reasons, final tune settings are different - and, since the EC997 does Sweep and Steady State horsepower testing, we have a choice of tests - from a dj style Sweep Test to Steady State.
Having a choice of those types of tests to do - and having been, firsthand, involved in all sorts of racing - AFM, AMA (250 GP #1,#2,#3,#4), WERA, CCS, Formula USA (750 National Champ and 6 USA Track records!) road racing, drag racing, MX, Speedway, dirttrack, scooter - we have had the opportunity to verify the results of different types of tests and their relevance to the real world operation -
Without a doubt - the Steady State test Mode is the most consistently superior method of tuning - anybody who has the capability to do it will echo that sentiment - it's only an arguable point with those who can't do it properly.
One of the reasons why the EC997 provide settings that work better in the real world is that combustion chamber temperatures are more in line with the actual operating temperatures that the engine - Tests done by Champion Spark Plugs at 4&6 Cycle, Chicago area, provided information that combustion chamber / spark plug temps, on a a common inertia dyne were 300f to 400f LOWER than the real world and the EC997 Steady State Test Mode - Nobody should ignore that - that means ignition timing AND fuel are incorrect when set at sub normal temps - too rich and too advanced is not un common error. (unless you are tuning FI - then it can be either too lean or rich)
On a TZ250? A dj dyno indicated that 3.1mm btdc was optimal ignition timing for best power - and the EC997 indicated 2.6mm btdc - if you knew gp bikes (or even rd350's like me!) that's a HUGE difference!
How much different? About 6 to 7 hp improvement on the EC997 at 2.6mm - and the bike, now, "ripped" on the track instead of droning in sorry misery - it lost a bunch of power on the dj dyno, but, who cared anymore, the EC997 said that the bike was better and the track performance verified it. The only dissenting opinion was the inertia dyne test results.
Given an open mind, desire and equipment, one could make up their own mind -
As for me? I've been here and I've been there - And I like "here" a LOT better!
If I had to resort to sweep tests, only, I'd quit this line of work (boy - would some people be happy!)
Final statement - "It's not important which dyno you use - it's only the amount of power improvement that's important." has never been said by a qualified tuner who has the ability to use modern designed dyno systems and verify results on the track.
Never.
"True HP" vs. "False HP"
"True HP" is a term that signified that the rear wheel horsepower figure was derived from the actual power delivered to the drive roller - nothing added (except normal dyne system parasitic drag).
If some other dynamometer company provides HP figures that will conform to that, they can use the term "True HP". If they don't, then they can't.
Truth in advertising.
If they did, then their dyne systems would at least read the same as another "True HP" dyne system - eliminating a bit more confusion in the industry. (but what would make the internet boring).
Superflow has agreed in principle, so has Mustang and Land and Sea.
Does altitude make any difference at all in HP?
The engine couldn't give 2 hoots at what altitude it is tested at - it only cares what the air pressure, temp and humidity is.
Sea level at 28.02 inches baro is exactly the same as 4000ft/1000 meters at 28.02 inches, as far as the engine is concerned -
When we test at 5000 ft, we get virtually exactly the same power (corrected to atmos. conditions, of course) as we do at sea level - It's just about 24%-25% less on the track and on the EC997 dyno!
I am confused (sometimes, easy to do - but not this time :-) why some dyno manufacturer's insist on putting altitude on their charts and having the dyno operator swear that it's a factor....... Might as well swear that there's some Merlin the Magician reason as to why one should test in 4th gear!!!
Crank HP vs. True Rear Wheel HP
That's a tough one - and LONG....
The short?
Take crank HP, subtract 14.5% (please don't email me and ask - I won't answer - search SAE and old Yamaha), take that, and subtract around 10% to 15% and you'll get about True HP at rear wheel.
The actual formula contains a curve for power loss through gears and there's another curve for power lost in a tire....
Remember, too - that you are only likely to get a crank number from the manufacturer and that's probably a "good" one that the marketing department is providing... (sound of blowing up marketing and sales balloon? :-) That's not everybody - but it has happened - leaving names out! :-)
When someone gets engineering data from engineering...... give me a call - :-)
What TEST would you suggest that I ask for when I Go to a Factory Pro Dyno Center?
Ask for the Steady State data, base and final tests - that has the 4 Gas EGA information and you can see the gas differences and how it relates to True HP - and you get the True HP numbers -
Some EC997 operators who are afraid that the information is too confusing and just give the owner the Quick Sweep (rough dj simulation) to keep - Get the True information - we can always work with that here, at 800 869-0497. Marc
posted May 02, 2004 12:05 PM
LOL!! No, but I wanted to tune my bike with the best tool available...and I have no confidence in either the dynojet dynos or the local monkeys running them. I had one company suggest that I could build a map for myself on their dynojet dyno.....no tailpipe sniffer, no tech support, nothing. They just held out their hands for about $200.
Basically I did some homework and realized that although the Factory Pro dyno would produce a smaller number, it would create a better running bike..and that is what I got...a stupidly fast bike without the sharp edges and hiccups of a genericly mapped bike.
I will say that when I do buy a dyno (someday I hope) it will probably be from Factory Pro. I also realized that I still have some animosity towards dynojet for some of the crappy jet kits they put out and how many hours I've wasted trying to make them work....and yet the Factory Pro jet kits don't seem to have the same problems.
posted May 02, 2004 12:49 PM
How can they build a good map without a sniffer???? Shops you was talking about???? Mine was built with a sniffer... Thats gotta be the best way..
posted May 02, 2004 01:03 PM
I agree. Without a sniffer, the dyno is not nearly as useful. I suspect that like a lot of things, it is used as a tool for the posers: a guy rolls in on his "hog" with a 98" S and S mill and wants to know the numbers. He doesn't give a shit about the tuning, he just wants the big number.
posted May 02, 2004 01:07 PM
Mine was bulit on a dj250 with sniffer.... I wouldn't have one built without sniffer... Gonna have a new one built this year made a few changes since last one..
posted May 02, 2004 01:44 PM
Were is Okotoks? How much did it cost to have your mapped built? Maybe a can ride out there sometime this summer and have one built for me.
Needs a life
Full throttle!
Posts: One MEEEEEELLION
posted May 02, 2004 02:35 PM
What a stupid, spammy waste of time to read! Get a life and go ride your bike! The only dyno that matters is the butt-dyno!
____________
82 Gpz750, 84 Ninja 900, 2000 ZX12R (Muzzy Big Bore Kit), *another* 2000 ZX12R (Muzzy custom stroke crank 1341cc motor), 2004 ZZR1200, 2005 ZX10R, 2007 ZX14, 2008 Concours 14, 2014 Versys 650, 2014 Yamaha WR450F, 2015 Ninja H2
posted May 02, 2004 03:11 PM
Okotoks is about 15 minutes south of Calgary. It cost just under $300 to have all the runs and the building of the map done.
quote: "What a stupid, spammy waste of time to read! Get a life and go ride your bike! The only dyno that matters is the butt-dyno!"
SWFT: what an ignorent comment to make. Spammy waste of time??? A good portion of the bandwidth used by this site and many other is spent talking about horsepower and dynos and how much pipe A gained over B. A dyno is just a tool. Do you build your engines without a torque whench also? See, that is also a tool that is essential.....there is little to no difference. Here's a real question for you: do you even build your own engines? Understand that I built this engine from the ground up....it is certainly not the first and it won't be the last. I, unlike some, see the value in investing in methods that allow me to safely ensure that this thing will hang together despite all of the use and abuse I'm going to dish out to it.
And as far as the butt dyno goes.......see the torque wrench comment.
posted May 02, 2004 07:02 PM
Edited By: zx12girl on 4 May 2004 17:23
My 1270 runs about 158-160mph in the 1/4 with me on it....Now, take off a few MPH if your a member of TFA
uuummm...Correction....158-160 is with the NOS button engaged....It has been a while since I have NOT hit the NOS button.
Only about 151-152 on the motor....
All times are America/Va [ This thread is 3 pages long: 123Next» ]